Rosie the Reviewer: a WW2 movies and shows podcast · Rosie the Reviewer

Ep 80 – Battle of Britain – Finally Some RAF... Guy Hamilton's Air Epic

·51 min·10 clips

Sam and Margie open with *Battle of Britain*, Guy Hamilton's 1969 war film about the fighting over Great Britain in 1940. It is based on Derek Wood and Derek Dempster's 1961 book *The Narrow Margin: The Battle of Britain and the Rise of Air Power from 1930 to 1949*. The hosts immediately notice how many characters the film throws at the viewer, and they are honest that most of them are hard to keep straight. The film does not really work like a tidy character drama. It has more of a documentary feel, and that is part of what keeps drawing Sam and Margie back in. Sam says movies like this do not really get made anymore, and the two of them spend a fair amount of time circling that point as they talk through the battle's shape. One of the episode's strongest stretches comes when they talk about the women working in the control room. The film lets them do actual work instead of treating them like background. The hosts notice how the senior officers try moving the girls beyond the earshot of the loudspeakers because of the language, and they point out the contradiction without losing the humor or the seriousness. The episode then turns to August 13, 1940, also known as Eagle Day. Sam and Margie explain that in July the Germans had mostly focused on mine laying in the Channel and the North Sea, plus convoys and shipping, but that by early August much of the battle had moved onto the island itself. That shift matters because it marks a real change in how the war was being fought. From there, the film's airfield attacks become the main event. The Germans try to knock out the RAF on the ground. The hosts draw attention to the line about a Spitfire not being able to be in two places at once. They laugh at the way the movie makes the Germans sound almost giddy while saying it. At the same time, they point out that the line is real and appears in the book too. That gives the scene extra weight. From there, the discussion opens up into the Spitfire's reputation and why it became such a lasting icon. Sam and Margie also work through the basic differences between the aircraft. The Me 109s are better at climbing and diving. The Spitfires are better at turning. The film keeps pushing the Spitfire's status, and the hosts notice that it is doing the work of myth as much as history. That leads into a broader point about popular memory. The Spitfire has become the fighter plane many people picture first when they think of World War II. The episode treats that idea as familiar, but still worth examining. It is one of the places where the movie's British perspective comes through clearly. The hosts keep the tone warm and dry even when the subject is grim. They move between plot, reaction, and historical explanation with ease. They are comfortable pointing out when the film is silly, and just as comfortable pointing out when it is careful. Because the movie keeps so many figures in play, the conversation never settles on one neat emotional center. That is part of what makes the episode work. It asks the listener to think about scale, not just story. It also asks what a war film looks like when it tries to honor a battle instead of inventing a single protagonist to carry it. By the end, the episode has sketched the film's broad shape, its sense of place and date, and its obsession with aircraft performance. It has also made room for the control-room workers who keep the battle moving. The result is a discussion that stays interested in process as much as spectacle, and that balance gives the episode its staying power.

As heard by us

A crowded World War II film gets a clear-eyed review that values its documentary style.

Guy Hamilton's Battle of Britain gets a review that fits a large, crowded war film. The hosts treat it as a documentary-style account of the battle, and they give proper weight to the many real-life figures, even when a few begin to blur together.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

A big RAF war epic, unpacked as a sprawling, documentary-style Battle of Britain watch.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Rosie the Reviewer: a WW2 movies and shows podcast