Rosie the Reviewer: a WW2 movies and shows podcast · Rosie the Reviewer

Ep 100 – So Proudly We Hail – US Army Nurses on Bataan and Corregidor

·1 hr 1 min·4 clips

Olivia pulls a grenade into her dungarees and walks toward the Japanese as the nurses try to escape.

1. Rosie the Reviewer marks its 100th episode with So Proudly We Hail, a 1943 film about American army nurses in the Philippines during World War II. 2. Sam hosts with Margie, and both speak as World War II media reviewers who compare the film to Juanita Redmond's memoir I Served on Bataan and Elizabeth M. Norman's We Band of Angels. 3. The episode asks what So Proudly We Hail is really doing: history, propaganda, or wartime storytelling about women. 4. The hosts note that the film was directed by Mark Sandrich, written by Alan Scott, and loosely based on Lieutenant Colonel Juanita Redmond's 1943 account. 5. They explain that First Lieutenant Eunice Hatchett advised on the film, which matters because the movie claims some realism about Army nursing. 6. The discussion places the story in Manila, Bataan, Corregidor, and Melbourne, with the opening card describing eight surviving nurses arriving in Australia on May 5, 1942. 7. Sam and Margie then rewind to the Philippine-American War, the Spanish-American War of 1898, and the American occupation that followed. 8. They describe how the Americans kept the Philippines for its resources, expanded Manila, and used English, construction, and military power to reshape daily life. 9. The episode explains that by the late 1930s many nurses saw the Philippines as a two-year peacetime assignment with swimming, dances, and officers' parties. 10. When Japan attacked Pearl Harbor on December 7, 1941, the nurses were suddenly treating battlefield injuries instead of routine medical cases. 11. The hosts emphasize that the real nurses were moved from Manila to Bataan, worked in jungle hospitals, and sometimes slept outdoors because the wards were overwhelmed. 12. They mention a nurse being shown how to load and fire a pistol, a detail that captures how quickly the war became immediate and personal. 13. The film's character work gets a mixed response, especially Joan O'Doul's flirtation, Davy's command role, and Olivia Darcy's hostility after surviving a torpedo attack. 14. Sam and Margie describe Olivia's grief over a fiancé killed at Pearl Harbor and the way the movie turns her into a more melodramatic figure than the memoir supports. 15. They also note that the film includes a close-up propaganda style, a 'miracle' opening card, and repeated calls to adult nurses as 'girls.' 16. The hosts spend time on the hospital scenes, including bombed wards, reused dressings, malaria medicine shortages, and the nurses helping patients roll under beds during air raids. 17. They describe the real surrender context around Bataan, Corregidor, and General MacArthur's evacuation, which frames why the nurses are trapped and why supply lines collapse. 18. The episode's tone is conversational and critical, with Sam and Margie balancing dry humor, historical explanation, and specific complaints about romantic tropes and wartime stereotypes. 19. Viewers interested in WWII films, nurses, or the Philippines will get the most from this episode. 20. Viewers wanting a strict scene-by-scene plot recap or a romance-focused discussion may skip it.

As heard by us

A brisk, history-minded look at a wartime drama about nurses, sacrifice, and movie-star glamour.

Rosie the Reviewer reaches its 100th episode with So Proudly We Hail, a 1943 film about American army nurses in the Philippines, and the discussion is strongest when it stays close to Juanita Redmond's memoir and the wartime pressure around Bataan.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want WWII movie talk that keeps one eye on the history behind So Proudly We Hail.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Rosie the Reviewer: a WW2 movies and shows podcast