Rosedale Baptist Church Podcast

How to Select a New Pastor – 1 Timothy 3:1-13

·47 min·4 clips
Pastor Toole recounts feeling called to pastor at 18 and the strong, sacrificial commitment it demands.
Pastor Scott Toole begins with 1 Timothy 3:1 and the title How to Select a New Pastor. He explains the office of a bishop as a good work, then uses the verse to ask who should be trusted to carry it. The qualifications move through blameless conduct, being the husband of one wife, vigilance, sobriety, good behavior, hospitality, teaching, and restraint around wine. He ties the discussion to the earlier instruction about women, silence in the churches, and authority over the man, keeping both subjects in the same context. He also pauses over the pastor's titles, explaining bishop as episkopos, the overseer, and an authority who is still a human under-shepherd. From there, Toole presses into the question of calling. He argues that a man who can do anything other than pastoring may not be called to pastor, because a true calling should be hard to hold down. His own story includes throwing boxes at Dominic's Warehouse. He remembers feeling miserable and as though he were spinning his wheels while working a secular job after Bible college. Bible college then becomes a kind of endurance test. Toole recalls studying pastoral theology in a class he remembers as around 200 students, though he says it may have been less, and watching the number shrink after the first year and again after the second. He also describes classes from eight until one, an hour drive to a full-time job on the north side, and returns that could come after one in the morning. Saturday ministry that ran from almost sunup past sundown and Sunday ministry left little room to breathe. The point keeps returning: if a calling cannot sustain a man through that pressure, he may not be called. The message carries that same question into pastoral ministry. He says they have sent out 12 men, perhaps 13, to pastor, although not all remain in pastoral work. Toole distinguishes an assistant pastor from a pastor by responsibility, stresses, and expectations, and says men can drop away when those demands change. The final movement imagines how a church should examine a candidate. Toole would call every person who knows the man, speak with people who know those references, and even reach back to a third-grade teacher while seeking God's confirmation and stepping out by faith toward the good and acceptable and perfect will of God.

As heard by us

Pastor Scott Toole turns 1 Timothy 3 into a sober account of pastoral calling and candidate discernment.

Pastor Scott Toole frames the choice of a new pastor as both a biblical matter and a test of congregational discernment. Working through 1 Timothy 3, he treats the office of bishop as a good work, then lingers over qualifications such as blamelessness, fidelity, sobriety, good…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Want a sermon on selecting a new pastor that starts in 1 Timothy 3, then moves into pastoral calling and serious candidate vetting?

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on