RONZHEIMER. · Paul Ronzheimer

Warum Trump Putins Krieg nicht stoppen kann. Mit Bojan Pancevski

·48 min·3 clips

One day before the Munich Security Conference, Zelensky privately told his closest advisers the peace talks had failed and ordered them to draft a three-year war plan.

1. RONZHEIMER. episode features Paul Ronzheimer interviewing Bojan Pancevski, Wall Street Journal correspondent, about the state of Ukraine-Russia peace negotiations recorded on a Wednesday morning in Geneva. 2. Pancevski is described as having been more optimistic about negotiations than Ronzheimer in previous appearances; he confirms he has now also become skeptical. 3. The episode's central question is why negotiations have stalled again around the same two issues — territory and security guarantees — that have been the sticking points for nearly a year. 4. The single most significant new piece of intelligence Pancevski shares: Zelensky convened his inner-circle presidential staff one day before the Munich Security Conference and told them the talks had failed, ordering preparation of a three-year war plan. 5. Pancevski's sources include three of Zelensky's closest advisers who attended the meeting and were described as 'totally shocked' because they had been preparing for a referendum on a potential deal. 6. On territory, Putin wants unoccupied Donetsk oblast — which Russia has not conquered — handed over for free as his minimum condition for a deal; Zelensky has privately signalled he might accept this if given robust security guarantees. 7. The security guarantee problem: Zelensky wants US commitments that pass through Congress and have legal force, while Trump has only offered verbal assurances, including a personal promise in Davos that America would protect Ukraine's airspace after any deal. 8. Russia's position was conveyed to Macron's national security adviser in Moscow two weeks before recording: Yuri Ushakov, Putin's long-serving foreign policy adviser, told the French envoy that Russia will never sign any document permitting NATO or Western troops to be stationed on Ukrainian soil. 9. Pancevski describes an internal Ukrainian split: Kyrylo Budanov, the new presidential-office head and former intelligence chief, leads a camp pushing for a deal, while the fired former chief Andriy Yermak — still in Zelensky's orbit despite dismissal — is working against negotiations. 10. Almost every European and US negotiating partner Pancevski knows was relieved when Yermak was removed and regards his continued influence as 'a toxic story.' 11. Zelensky's position has worsened since 2023: he fired most competent generals, including Valery Zaluzhny who was dispatched to London as ambassador, and the war has gone badly ever since; an election would likely result in Zaluzhny defeating him. 12. Trump cannot legally bind the US to defending Ukraine before midterm elections because his core voters chose him specifically on promises of no more foreign military entanglements, and a treaty committing America to war with Russia would breach that promise directly. 13. Steve Witkoff, Trump's chief negotiator, assessed deal prospects at 50-50 and did not attribute the stall specifically to Ukraine, as Pancevski reports. 14. Pancevski argues Putin is not motivated by economics but by imperial ideology: he sees Ukraine as a historical accident that must be corrected, is willing to let many Russians die, and would likely use any ceasefire as a pause before reinvading. 15. Sergei Chemezov, head of Russian state arms conglomerate Rostec and Putin's former KGB colleague from their joint posting in Dresden in the 1980s, has become Russia's de facto second-most-powerful figure and has successfully scaled weapons production to fire dozens of ballistic missiles and hundreds of drones per assault despite Western sanctions. 16. Western sanctions have partial effectiveness: Pancevski cites Trump's single tweet threatening to sanction Rosneft and Lukoil causing immediate business cancellations, including Microsoft and Vodafone ending contracts with a Rosneft-owned refinery in Brandenburg. 17. The sanctions' fundamental weakness is circumvention via Turkey, UAE, Kazakhstan, and Turkmenistan — demonstrated by the explosion in German trade volumes with these countries, which Pancevski argues reflects Russian re-importation of components including chips and optical devices. 18. Pancevski is cautiously optimistic that the front line will remain relatively static and Ukraine will not collapse quickly, but warns the air war is the genuine existential threat to civilian life in Ukrainian cities. 19. Foreign-policy analysts, journalists, and anyone following Ukraine-Russia negotiations will find this episode unusually specific due to Pancevski's named source access inside Zelensky's circle. 20. Listeners seeking a balanced Russia perspective or basic introductory coverage will find the episode's depth and pro-Western framing assumes extensive prior knowledge.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from RONZHEIMER.