"Who Cares About the Lore?" with Duncan Fyfe

March 17, 2026·1 hr 15 min·6 clips

How did a 20-year-old concept artist convince a veteran designer to junk his Shakespearean vision for giant bugs and mushrooms?

The hook is lore itself. Rob sets up Duncan Fyfe's article as a way into The Elder Scrolls, a major franchise in a culture that often wants canon clean, sortable, and settled. Duncan gets there through the games he played, including Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim, and Fallout. What follows is a generous argument about mess. A setting can look loose by ordinary continuity standards and still feel stronger because of that looseness, especially when the people making it do not treat canon like a locked display case. Morrowind becomes the pivot. Duncan suggests it may have been the last Elder Scrolls made by people who were not already fans of The Elder Scrolls. That sounds almost wrong at first. Rob and Duncan sit with that discomfort, because affection can keep a world intact, but distance can make it stranger and more alive. The conversation moves outside Bethesda too. The Wrath of Khan comes up through Nicholas Meyer, whose distance from Star Trek may have helped him see what could be done with it. Battletech enters the mix as well, with Rob recalling a Harebrained Schemes designer who made a Battletech game he admired while admitting she did not especially love the setting. That kind of admission can sting. The point is not that contempt makes better work. Duncan is careful about that. The people making Morrowind took the job seriously and became invested in the fiction, even if fandom was not their starting point. Rob keeps the pace loose but sharp. The episode works less like a lore explainer and more like a conversation about why old worlds sometimes need someone at the table who can love the assignment without protecting every old choice.

As heard by us

A smart, relaxed case for Elder Scrolls lore as a productive, unruly mess.

Remap Radio makes Elder Scrolls lore feel less like homework and more like a useful mess. Rob and Duncan Fyfe begin with Fyfe's article, "Who Cares About the Lore?", then dig into why a major fantasy series might be stronger without a neat timeline or clean canon.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If you like lore debates that turn into media criticism, start here.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Remap Radio