Real Life Real Crime · Real Life Real Crime Productions

Real Life Real Crime | Justice For Hailey Ep 31

February 18, 2026·44 min·4 clips
Scott Roeder explains why a 5-foot-tall woman couldn't hold an 8-pound shotgun horizontally to shoot herself.
The show opens with a sponsor read for Big J's Side Porch in Clinton, Louisiana. The ad runs through Cajun country cooking, cold beer, wings on Wednesdays, bingo on Thursday, and steak night on Friday. Then the case talk takes over. The speaker describes himself as a man of faith and says he tries to let Jesus guide his hand and his skill toward the truth. He says prayer and guidance matter because the families who live with these cases need support as well as answers. The conversation stays personal without losing the case. He talks about Barbara, Stella, and Tyler and says their heartbreak is real. He also says he has seen this kind of pain many times before. The point is not novelty. It is that the work still has to be done with empathy. The guest and host talk about fairness too. He says he will not consult on sexual assault crimes because he cannot be fair in those cases. He says his heart hurts too much for that kind of work. Every other kind of case stays on the table. He lists bank robberies, police shootings, self-defense stabbings, and death penalty cases. He describes that boundary as part of his north star. He wants his skill to be aimed by something steadier than instinct alone. The ending returns to the Hailey case with a blue dummy for Brooks Cleary and a pink dummy for Hailey in an apartment reconstruction. That visual is used to explain where she had to be standing when she was shot, and it reinforces the claim that she was murdered. The close is a direct plea for people to help if they can and keep pushing until justice lands.

As heard by us

A grief-heavy case talk that keeps returning to evidence, faith, and justice.

Real Life Real Crime folds a Hailey case discussion into faith, forensic work, and blunt frustration. The opening sponsor read runs long and the conversation drifts, but the episode keeps coming back to the same point: justice for Hailey matters, and the evidence should lead the…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a straight-shot plea for justice in Hailey's case.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on