Real Horror Stories · Real Horror Stories

Disappearing Without Answers and the Questions Left Behind

March 4, 2026·20 min·2 clips

I tore open the hollow floorboards under my bed and stood in horror at the human remains I found.

The episode opens with a first-person narrative from a man whose father, Joseph Smith, vanished when he was 13 years old. His mother, Rita Smith, claimed he ran away, but the narrator doubted this because all his father's belongings were left behind. The police and community search parties failed to find any clues, and the case went cold after three years. The narrator, however, never gave up, searching daily after school and feeling a persistent gut feeling his father was nearby. Eight years later, now 21 and studying criminology, he decides to revisit the last night he saw his father. He recalls his parents having a serious conversation in his room for privacy. Confronting his mother, Rita, she breaks down, begging him to stop his obsessive search, revealing her fear of losing him too. Later that night, driven by an inexplicable urge, he searches his room and notices the floorboards under his bed are a different color wood. He pries them open to discover human remains. His mother enters, holding a knife, and admits she killed his father that night, stabbing him in the throat, then hid the body under the floor. She attacks him, but he subdues her until police arrive. An autopsy confirms the remains are his father. Rita confesses but gives no motive; psychological evaluations suggest she may have paranoid personality disorder and schizophrenia. She is sentenced to life in prison. The narrator becomes a detective with the NYPD, specializing in missing persons cases. The episode then transitions to a second story narrated by Barry. Barry reveals he was kidnapped as a child, with his parents paying a ransom. Thirty years later, he returns to his hometown to visit family, including a nephew he's never met. Shortly after, he learns from the news that his nephew and other children have been kidnapped. He receives a phone call from a man claiming to be his childhood kidnapper, who says the children will die unless Barry rescues them alone. Barry goes to an abandoned warehouse, finds the children, and is attacked by the kidnapper. Police arrive but arrest Barry instead, finding him holding a knife. He is found guilty of kidnapping but sent to a mental health center. Psychiatrists diagnose him with trauma-induced dissociation, claiming the kidnapper and events were fabricated by his mind to achieve closure. Barry insists his experience was real and vows to prove it.

As heard by us

A disappearance story that moves from domestic denial to buried truth and ends in a bleak, unsettling psychological break.

A father goes missing when the narrator is 13, and the story lands hardest in the ordinary details that are left behind: the clothes, the car, the wallet, the search parties, and the sense that the official story never quite adds up.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play if you want a disappearance story that keeps getting stranger.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Real Horror Stories