Re-Solved Mysteries: An Unsolved Mysteries Podcast · Alison, Karlin and Eliza

My Humps Season 5 Episode 2 Part 1

·1 hr 13 min·4 clips

After 20 years in Bangladesh, Mahfouz Haq was captured, extradited, and pleaded guilty to 40 years in prison.

1. Re-Solved Mysteries Season 5, Episode 2 focuses on the 1989 killing of Todd Kelly in Hamilton, Indiana, and a Lake Champlain monster segment about “Champ.” 2. Hosts Eliza, Allison, and Karlyn narrate the recap and connect the Unsolved Mysteries cases to later updates and follow-up reporting. 3. The episode asks whether Mahfouz Haq acted alone in Todd Kelly’s death and how the Lake Champlain legend became a modern eyewitness story. 4. Hamilton, Indiana, is described as a lake town with 684 permanent residents that swells in summer with vacationers. 5. Christy Mutzfeld says she found Todd Kelly dead on August 9, 1989, after being with him two hours earlier. 6. Christy describes her earlier relationship with Todd, his marriage proposal after graduation, and her decision to say no because she was not ready. 7. Christy then dates Mahfouz Haq, who immigrated from Bangladesh as a baby and presents himself as outgoing and energetic. 8. The segment says Haq was later arrested with a friend for three robberies, including more than $100,000 in jewelry stolen from his aunt. 9. Christy says Haq became possessive during house arrest and told her he would kill any man he found with her and then kill her. 10. Days before the murder, Haq walks 10 miles to Christy’s home, confronts Todd Kelly, and asks whether he will stop seeing her. 11. Sheriff Mike McClelland describes a cleaned crime scene, missing bed sheets, a wiped blood spot near the bathroom, and Todd’s car wiped of fingerprints. 12. Police also find cigarette butts matching the brand Haq smoked and learn that Todd’s car keys are missing. 13. Witnesses see Haq barefoot on the road between 11 p.m. and 1 a.m. heading toward Todd’s house. 14. Christy says she heard noises outside the house, thought Todd’s comment about a dog explained them, and later believes Haq had entered while they were gone. 15. Todd’s father, Vernon Kelly, says the family believes Christy is withholding the truth and questions how one person could clean the scene and move the body alone. 16. Christy says Todd’s family barred her from the funeral and have been hard on her since the killing. 17. The hosts’ style is conversational, with side comments about weather in Astoria, Oregon, merch, and the odd details of 1980s hair and reenactments. 18. The pacing mixes recap, speculation, and update, with the Lake Champlain discussion adding a folklore break after the murder case. 19. Listeners who like cold-case timelines, true-crime updates, and regional folklore will get the most from this episode. 20. Listeners wanting a single-topic, fast-moving story without digressions may skip it.

As heard by us

A messy case recap with a long extradition detour.

The episode centers on a case that keeps widening, from the original crime to the long extradition process from India and the evidence assembled against Huck.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

A murder case recap with an India extradition, forensic breadcrumbs, and some wildly inconsistent reenactments.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Re-Solved Mysteries: An Unsolved Mysteries Podcast