Radio One Chicago

April 2020 | Live From The Lair with Tobias Wayland

·1 hr 10 min·5 clips
In 2017, Tobias Wayland saw three reports of a bat-like or bird-like humanoid creature in Chicago, sparking his Mothman investigation.
The host begins by asking Wayland about the circumstances behind the book. Wayland says that he and his wife Emily founded the Singular Fortean Society in 2016. He describes it as a news outlet and investigative group focused on paranormal reports, anomalies, and weird news. In April 2017, he noticed three unusual winged humanoid sightings in the Mutual UFO Network case management system. The reports described either a large bat-like creature or something bird-like and humanoid, which was more than enough to get his attention. He decided to write about them for the organization's website. At the time, there was little information available about the cases. He explains that MUFON has traditionally kept the results of its investigations relatively private. The conversation then turns to material Keel received while investigating the Mothman. Keel believed there might be some kind of disaster. He expected a widespread blackout along the East Coast. When the Silver Bridge collapsed, Keel was in his New York apartment rather than Point Pleasant. Wayland says hindsight helped Keel connect the sightings to the collapse. He finds no causal link between the Mothman reports and the disaster. Reports continued after the bridge collapsed, which complicates the idea of the creature as a warning. The oldest sighting he mentions is from Indiana in 1969. He describes the harbinger story as a way to give frightening events a purpose. That story can make a random tragedy feel less arbitrary within a cold and uncaring universe. At the close, the host recommends the book and points to its Chicago references, including chapter 13, the Pilsen video, and a bike messenger from Pilsen.

As heard by us

A Chicago-rooted Mothman story opens into a measured look at how fear becomes meaning.

This single-episode review follows the Lake Michigan Mothman as a doorway into paranormal belief, moving from strange sightings to the stories people build around them.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want the Mothman legend pulled toward Lake Michigan, Chicago texture, and the human need for a tidy story.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on