The Manosphere Feels Betrayed

April 2, 2026·25 min·2 clips

Why are Manosphere podcasters who helped elect Trump now turning against him over war and broken promises?

The fracture starts with disappointment. The guest says Andrew Schultz began getting cold feet after the big spending bill, while Israel-Gaza had not wound down, Ukraine-Russia had not wound down, and Trump had blocked the release of some Epstein files. The host lingers on motive. Was this just outrage over a politician breaking a promise, or was something more personal moving through these shows? The answer is personal. The guest says these voices had treated Trump and his team as outsiders, not as part of the deep state they distrusted. So the reversal hit hard. The Epstein files mattered because Trump and his allies had talked about naming names, unmasking predators, and releasing the files. For people already suspicious of hidden power, holding back some files made Trump look like any other politician. The host lands on the word betrayal. That is the frame for a coalition that wanted Trump to break norms in one direction, not just break them. The distinction matters. Trump could still break the system and norms, but the guest says he was not breaking them in the ways these supporters expected. Other grievances trail behind that. The conversation points to more Epstein chatter in the fall, then turns to how indiscriminate a lot of the ICE deportations were. Flagrant becomes the example. The guest says the guys on that show had talked to Trump about deportations and asked whether he could prioritize criminals while still leaving room for empathy toward some people seeking a path to citizenship. The politics stay messy. The segment is about what happens when anti-establishment faith runs into a president making reversals and governing choices his supporters did not expect.

As heard by us

A sharp account of why parts of Trump's manosphere orbit heard his reversals as political betrayal.

Radio Atlantic follows a Trump-aligned podcast circle as its expectations of disruption in Washington curdle into a more familiar kind of disappointment.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You will come out understanding why 'betrayal' was the precise word for what the manosphere felt.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Radio Atlantic