425: Making the Leap: Tim’s Journey to Full-Time Reselling

·1 hr 5 min·5 clips

Tim turned a $1,000 investment into $15,000 by discovering a collection of rare Tonner dolls at an estate sale.

In episode 425 of Pure Hustle Podcast, hosts Mike and Rolando interview Tim the Slim, a full-time reseller from northwest Montana. Tim was a K-12 music teacher for 10 years before making the switch 18 months ago. He explains that the decision was driven by a desire for family time, flexibility, and avoiding regret. Tim opened his eBay account at 18 and started with Magic: The Gathering cards and video games. His first big hit was retail arbitrage with Hot Wheels tracks from Hobby Lobby. Tim discusses his sourcing strategy, focusing on garage and estate sales, and presents himself as a bookseller to attract specific leads. He tracked his part-time reselling hours, averaging 20 per week, and calculated that tripling his effort could yield 1.5 times his teacher salary. With his wife's support and benefits from her teaching job, he made the leap. Tim shares his biggest scores: a set of original McDonald's hamburger decorations sold for $3,000, a $15,000 haul from Tonner dolls, and a vintage microphone flip. He emphasizes discipline, empathy from teaching, and the book 'Never Split the Difference' by Chris Voss. Tim advises part-time resellers to know their numbers and seek honest feedback before going full-time. He believes reselling is here to stay but may require adaptation to new platforms and AI. The episode ends with Tim holding Rolando accountable for learning to ride a bike.

As heard by us

Tim the Slim connects teaching, reselling, and negotiation through a practical case for empathy as business skill.

Tim the Slim's shift from teaching to full-time reselling gives this Pure Soul Podcast interview a clear question: when does a side pursuit become steady enough to live on?

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You get a candid interview with Tim the Slim about leaving teaching behind and selling full time.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Pure Hustle Podcast