PS You're Wrong: A Pop Culture Podcast · Shelby and Matt

Stranger Things Season 5 (Episode 319)

January 8, 2026·1 hr 20 min·10 clips

Shelby and Matt open with a theme-song bit, and that joke carries them into Stranger Things. From there they keep coming back to the locked-down town, the military presence, and the odd fact that everyone seems to accept all of it as normal. They are not buying it. The talk keeps circling the show's scale and the feeling that the scale is starting to crowd out the fun, especially once the pink flames and the rest of the chaos start piling up. The CGI takes plenty of heat. Jonathan's tower run is the clearest example, and they treat it like the sort of green-screen work that should never have made it to air. They are just as blunt about the desert-planet look. From there they compare the visuals to something lifted from a 1993 Power Rangers episode, and the repeated running-up-that-hill beat only makes things feel more tired. Sadie Sink gets a long, annoyed look. They think her role is too thin at first, then too boxed in once the story pushes her into the orphanage thread and the Henry Creel material. There is also a wheelchair, which leaves them confused, because the show keeps piling on ominous images and huge ideas without making the mechanics feel any less awkward. The hosts spend time trying to figure out why the design feels so off. Part of it is the costumed, built-for-epic language of the show running into effects that look cheaper than the script wants them to. Part of it is plain boredom. They keep saying the world-building asks for patience they are not always willing to give. The conversation stays loose, which is very on brand. They slip in an apology about a Taylor Swift documentary comment, then jump to Traders, Donna Kelsey, and the Golden Globes before signing off. Nothing gets treated as sacred. The whole thing plays like two people seeing how far a franchise can stretch before the seams start showing.

As heard by us

A blunt, skeptical take on Stranger Things with a sharp eye for spectacle.

Shelby and Matt keep the talk pointed, and their mix of irritation and amusement lands well enough. They zero in on the barricaded town, the military surveillance, and the pink-flame set piece, then push the joke a little further by treating the show's absurdity as something the…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If you want a blunt, funny read on Stranger Things season 4's messy final stretch.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from PS You're Wrong: A Pop Culture Podcast