PS You're Wrong: A Pop Culture Podcast · Shelby and Matt

Pop Culture Roundup #204

December 16, 2025·1 hr 4 min·5 clips

P.S. You're Wrong comes back with a rare pop culture roundup. It is the last one of 2025. Shelby and Matt seem relieved to have made it here. They start by talking about how television felt a little ho-hum for much of the year before suddenly roaring back with a run of shows and docu-series. Then they begin trying to sort through everything at once. Stranger Things comes up first. Heated Rivalry follows. I Love L.A. is in the mix too. So is the Taylor Swift docu-series. The conversation keeps moving because there is too much to pin down neatly. That loose motion is part of the appeal. They bounce between what they have seen and what they have only heard about. Heated Rivalry turns into a joke about how horny the show is supposed to be. The Taylor Swift discussion shifts into a side conversation about trans merch and the way a pop star's choices can ripple outward. From there they move into Charlie XCX's mockumentary project. The premise sounds goofy to them in a good way. They are intrigued by the idea of a fake documentary about the life of a pop star who is also a menace to everybody around her. That leads into a longer reflection on fame. They focus on the strange in-between places famous people spend their time. Green rooms, cabs, back halls, and other liminal spaces where the glamorous life starts to feel oddly hollow. The point is not that fame is fake. The point is that it is full of strange dead time. They sound most engaged when they are turning that idea over. The episode keeps that same rhythm as it moves through the rest of the roundup. There are jokes. There are half-finished thoughts. There are quick corrections and little reversals. The hosts are comfortable disagreeing without turning it into a fight. They close by looking ahead to Wake Up Dead Man and then to the next batch of holiday-season and early-2026 titles. The run of mentions makes the episode feel like a checklist, but the banter keeps it human. It is a conversational end-of-year dump of what is loud, what is weird, and what is still coming.

As heard by us

A brisk year-end pop-culture roundup with sharp takes and personality.

This year-end P.S. You're Wrong roundup moves quickly from TV sprawl to pop-star chatter, but it stays grounded when it lands on Stranger Things, Heated Rivalry, I Love L.A., the Taylor Swift docu-series, and the Charli XCX mockumentary.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Need a fast year-end pop culture catch-up with actual opinions?

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from PS You're Wrong: A Pop Culture Podcast