PS You're Wrong: A Pop Culture Podcast · Shelby and Matt

2025 Film Rankings (Episode 326)

March 12, 2026·2 hr 33 min·5 clips

Shelby and Matt celebrate their 8th annual film ranking episode of P.S. You're Wrong, going through their combined ranked list of 2025 movies from worst to best (covering roughly the bottom third of 114 films in this segment). They explain their golf-style scoring system with a 22-point average difference penalty for films only one host has seen. Highlights include passionate disagreement over Snow White (Shelby enjoyed its camp; Matt hated it), a lengthy debate on Luca Guadagnino's After The and its Me Too framing, Jurassic World Rebirth scoring a 55-point gap between them, and discussion of Pixar's Elio having queer content cut. The episode blends sharp film criticism with self-deprecating humor about their small but loyal audience and aspirations to eventual fame.

As heard by us

An annual movie-ranking back-and-forth that makes the spreadsheet talk feel earned.

P.S. You're Wrong turns its annual movie ranking into a running debate about what worked, what did not, and why a Best Picture nominee can still split the room. Shelby and Matt are strongest when the list turns into a conversation, and this one has real snap.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

For when you want one more annual movie ranking before the Oscars proper.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from PS You're Wrong: A Pop Culture Podcast