Press Box Chronicles · Press Box Chronicles

The Most Insane MLB Clubhouse Of All-Time: Tony Gwynn And The 1984 San Diego Padres

·23 min·2 clips
Three Padres managers get ejected as a wild brawl erupts with fans joining the fight in Atlanta.
Jeff Perlman opens by treating the 1984 San Diego Padres like a wild, odd team that somehow became unforgettable. He makes it clear right away that they did not win the World Series. He also makes it clear that he thinks they were unforgettable anyway. The whole thing feels like a memory board he keeps returning to. He starts with himself, too. Back in 1979, he was a seven-year-old watching Movie of the Week TV culture when that still meant something. That detour matters because it shows how he approaches sports stories. He is not chasing tidy nostalgia. He is chasing the strange, sticky stuff that stays in your head. From there he lands on the Padres. They are cocky. They are arrogant. They are hated. Tony Gwynn is the exception, and Perlman keeps stressing that the rest of the roster could rub just about everyone the wrong way. Greg Nettles gets no love. Steve Garvey gets no love. Alan Wiggins gets hated in remarkable ways. Eric Schall is described as an arch-conservative starting pitcher who is widely deplored. Dick Williams gets treated like the kind of manager everybody already had a problem with. Perlman keeps building the same point from different angles. The Padres threw inside. They slid dirty. They carried themselves like they wanted the smoke. He does not soften that. He pushes harder on it. That is the engine of the episode. Then he drops into August 12, 1984, at Fulton County Stadium in Atlanta. He does not romanticize the place. It is one of those old shitty stadiums that should have been condemned long ago. The Braves and Padres are sitting in first and second place in the National League West, and nobody involved seems interested in being polite about it. Pascual Perez starts the mess by hitting Alan Wiggins with the first pitch of the game. Wiggins stares him down, and the tension is immediate. Later, in the second inning, Ed Whitson drills Perez after Perez squares to bunt. Perez walks toward him with the bat, the umpire grabs him, and the benches clear. Warnings go out to both teams. The game is already out of control. Perlman loves that part because it is the whole Padres myth in one ugly little sequence. A pitch becomes a stare-down. A stare-down becomes retaliation. Retaliation becomes a bench-clearing scene. That is how he tells it, fast and unsentimental and a little amazed. He keeps stacking the characters until the clubhouse feels overfull on purpose. Nobody gets presented as clean or noble. Everybody is a little much. That is the appeal. The episode never pretends the Padres were great in a tidy, record-book way. It argues they were great in the way a disaster can be great if you lived through it. By the end, Perlman is back where he started, talking about how teams can fall apart so quickly that they get forgotten when they really should be remembered. He sounds like someone who has gone back to the footage more than once and still cannot quite believe what he is seeing. The result is less a clean history lesson than a loud love letter to a team that burned bright, pissed people off, and vanished before the world had a chance to settle down.

As heard by us

A swaggering, messy clubhouse story where the 1984 Padres keep colliding with bad blood and baseball chaos.

Jeff Perlman treats the 1984 San Diego Padres as a story of swagger, bad blood, and dysfunction, with Tony Gwynn standing out inside a clubhouse that drew plenty of dislike.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want the 1984 Padres story told like a fast clubhouse cautionary tale.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on