Pop Shop Podcast · Billboard

Rihanna Returns to Her Old ‘Friend’ Music, But Is ‘Smurfs’ Song the Musical Return Fans Wanted?

·40 min·3 clips
Sleep Token just scored the largest streaming week ever for a hard rock album, defying all expectations.
When a new pop release surfaces, Pop Shop has opinions. Keith and Katie take on the question the whole music internet is still turning over — whether the new release qualifies as the comeback fans have long been anticipating — and the answer, like most pop verdicts, lands somewhere around 'we'll see.' Then Morgan Wallen drops a new album, and the hosts go track by track with the kind of specificity that comes from covering charts for a living. 'Falling Apart' is the first track Katie flags. 'TN' follows, and one host calls it a master class in country songwriting, not casually but the way a chart editor would. That's where the hosts pull the credits and find Ashley Gourley's name alongside John Byron, Chase McGill, Jeff Warburton, and others. Three of those writers are appearing on the album for the first time, and the credits get read through mid-conversation, not as a tangent but as the main event. 'Missing' and 'If You Were Mine' both collect their own annotations in the running tally. One host admits she's at track 22 with 15 songs still to go, which means part two of the Wallen review is already booked for next week. Pop Shop does not pretend an album is absorbed when it isn't. Whether Wallen's collaborators produce cohesion across the record or something closer to reliable familiarity comes up and doesn't quite resolve; the hosts circle it and move forward. The title track, also track one, gets called most likely to top fan listening tallies. The Tate McRae collaboration is named as the song with the best shot at pulling in listeners from outside Wallen's existing base. 'Eyes Are Closed' is the track Katie marked with the word 'hit,' and that is where the episode lands. Before the sign-off, the hosts play the song's closing hook: 'Can you feel me in the air, baby, like a ghost? / Who do you see when your eyes are closed?' Keith is Billboard's Managing Director of Charts and Data Operations; Katie is Executive Digital Director on the West Coast, and they've been covering this beat long enough that pulling songwriter credits is just how they listen. They're recording in a studio Keith flags at the top as having a squeaky chair and a wobbly table — a strange opener for a chart podcast, and somehow right. A new pop release and Wallen's new album are both on the table, and Pop Shop is the show that covers both without ranking them. Songwriter credits get real airtime here: the hosts look them up and read them aloud rather than folding them into a summary. When one host calls a track really great, the names of who wrote it follow in the same breath. Of all the tracks discussed, 'TN' — Tennessee wordplay, rotating writers — ends up as the episode's most closely examined song.

As heard by us

A loose but useful Pop Shop episode, strongest when it weighs Morgan Wallen's songs against credits, chart movement, and crossover potential.

Despite the Rihanna-in-the-title setup, this Pop Shop episode lands most clearly when Keith Caulfield and Katie Atkinson settle into Morgan Wallen's new album and treat the songs like both pop products and chart problems.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Morgan Wallen dropped a sprawling album -- Katie still has 15 songs left, but they are already calling hits and reading out every songwriter on the credits.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on