Pop Shop Podcast · Billboard

'Late Show With Stephen Colbert' Cancellation Marks a New Late-Night Landscape for Musicians

·46 min·3 clips
Travis Scott's Jack Boys 2 album debuts at number one with only five days of chart activity.
Coldplay got them first. Katie says the kiss cam news reached her on vacation, which is funny because of course this is the sort of pop culture gravity she and Keith cannot leave alone. Keith calls it unifying, then the bit spreads into affairs, job losses, families getting dragged into the mess, and Coldplay somehow becoming proof that music can still pull everyone into the same ridiculous conversation. Very Pop Shop. From there, they move into late night as a place for musical guests. Colbert's taste comes up quickly. Katie and Keith wonder whether the bookings reflect Stephen Colbert, John Batiste, or the overlap between their musical worlds. Mavis Staples feels like the cleanest example. One host remembers seeing that she may be Colbert's favorite musician, so an early booking feels personal, not random. Then the roll call starts. Noah Cyrus, Lorde, the Doobie Brothers, King Princess, Gypsy with Audra McDonald, Pavement, Just in Time with Jonathan Groff, Megan Maroney, the Voids, Paris Paloma, Father John Misty, the Warren Treaty, Leon Thomas, Nicole Scherzinger, Kane Brown, and John Batiste all pass through. It is a lot, and that is the fun of it. Late night booking can still be curated, odd, theatrical, country, indie, Broadway, and close enough to the charts to make Billboard people keep notes. But it is not every night. Keith says Colbert did not always have a musical guest, while Katie explains that she tracks those appearances for Billboard's overnight team. That spreadsheet used to matter more plainly. In the album sales era, one performance could show up as a chart bump, so knowing who played where was useful. Now the money and audience habits feel different. Keith points to financial decisions and ratings that used to be much bigger, but they both still sound fond of the ritual. Even the end circles back to Coldplay: Sky Full of Stars, spoof videos, SportsCenter, BBC Radio 1, and a fake on mic embrace carry the joke out.

As heard by us

A loose, industry-minded look at what Colbert's cancellation means for musicians and late night's shrinking TV impact.

Pop Shop Podcast treats CBS's decision to cancel The Late Show With Stephen Colbert as a practical industry story: what late night still offers musicians when TV audiences and chart bumps are smaller than they used to be.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Two Billboard editors trace Colbert's musical guest list and explain why late night no longer moves the charts.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on