Pop Shop Podcast · Billboard

Lady Gaga’s Record-Breaking Rio Show Has Us Wondering: Could the U.S. Ever Host a Concert That Big?

·40 min·3 clips
Could Los Angeles ever host a free concert for 2.5 million people like Lady Gaga did in Rio?
Keith Caulfield opens Kylie-obsessed — he was at one of her concerts recently, can't stop thinking about her, and has song references going before the show has properly introduced itself. Katie Atkinson gets pulled in fast, and a full Kylie recap gets promised for later. The question underneath everything is whether the United States could ever pull off a concert at that scale, and Los Angeles becomes the extended test case. The process doesn't land anywhere. Santa Monica beach comes up first: too narrow, no parking, out. There are the free blanket concerts at the Santa Monica Pier, where ticketed fans sit on the pier and the general public spreads out on the sand below — held up as a loose proof of concept, even if the scale has nothing to do with what's actually being asked. Griffith Park comes up and sits there without resolution. Swan paddle boats on Echo Lake — or Silver Lake, one of them isn't sure which — get proposed as potential audience seating, and neither host finds that especially absurd. Coachella is the closest thing America has to a large, flat, open piece of land; it gets dismissed immediately: not Los Angeles. Central Park in New York comes up briefly, capacity unknown. Camp Flog Gnaw, Rolling Loud, Pride events downtown, shows outside at Hollywood Park near SoFi Stadium — each comes up as the nearest L.A. equivalent, and each turns out to be a different category of thing. Keith and Katie agree that Billboard's touring writer is the person who should actually field this question, and then keep going anyway. Near the close, gloves come up — specifically, wearing them in 60-degree weather — in a digression that comes out of nowhere and fits. The episode was recorded on a Monday, the Met Gala is happening that day, and there's a cheerful aside before the wrap. Keith has been steering toward a specific ending the whole time, the destination being Frank Sinatra by Cake, and the setup runs longer than expected. Katie figures it out just before he gets there. The Kylie recap presumably happened somewhere in the middle. The outdoor show question doesn't get resolved.

As heard by us

Gaga's Rio crowd becomes a sharp pop-news question about whether American cities have the space to match that scale.

Lady Gaga's record-breaking Rio show sends Pop Shop Podcast into a surprisingly civic question: could a U.S. city, especially Los Angeles, host a concert that large?

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Two Billboard editors can't figure out where in America you'd even put a massive outdoor concert -- and find the question more interesting than any answer.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on