Pop Shop Podcast · Billboard

Controversy Is Sabrina Carpenter's 'Best Friend' With Scandalized Reaction to New Album Cover

·36 min·2 clips
Why is Sabrina Carpenter's album cover, showing her on all fours with hair pulled, sparking a fierce debate about art and feminism?
Manchild opens the board at number one. Keith Caulfield and Katie Atkinson begin in familiar Pop Shop territory, running through Hot 100 and Billboard 200 movement before settling into Sabrina Carpenter's album-cover uproar. Mariah Carey gets her milestone too. Her Type Dangerous debut gives Keith the clean chart stat he can land quickly before the conversation shifts to context. Then Sabrina becomes the main event. The hosts tie the Manchild win to the noise around her album announcement, especially the reaction on The View and the internet. Katie is not buying the outrage. Her read is pretty simple: get on board with Sabrina's bit or skip the show, because the music has already made its lane clear. Parent mode enters the chat. Katie says she chooses what her kids hear, down to playing the clean radio edit of Manchild in the car. Keith leaves that one to Katie, then opens up the bigger question of what people think they are protecting children from, and where regular radio listening turns into panic. Madonna comes up for a reason. The comparison is not a neat career match. It is about the old cycle of adult pop women getting hit with think-of-the-children panic once the work gets provocative. Sabrina, they argue, is not burying the premise. Short and Sweet is described in the transcript as explicit, sexual, and adult, so the new cover backlash feels more like continuity than a surprise turn. The ending gets nicely ridiculous. A chart-stat tangent about Manchild, Babyface, the Supremes, and Diana Ross somehow turns into the imaginary famous band Child Face. Very Pop Shop. They close by joking about going out on the fictional band Manchild's one charting song, Especially for You, which is exactly the chart nerd spiral this show does best.

As heard by us

A pointed Pop Shop episode on Sabrina Carpenter's chart win, album-cover backlash, and the recurring panic over women in pop.

Billboard's Pop Shop uses Sabrina Carpenter's "Manchild" debuting at No. 1 on the Hot 100 as the entry point for a broader fight over pop, sexuality, and who gets to define an artist's audience.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want Sabrina Carpenter chart drama, album-cover backlash, and a Mariah Carey milestone in one brisk pop detour.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on