The Smurl Family Haunting Part 1

·35 min·10 clips

It starts like a remembered scare. The host explains that the haunting led to a 1991 straight-to-TV movie, one he watched too young and still finds genuinely frightening. Then the story gets domestic, which makes it nastier. According to the telling, the family dealt with activity for 15 years, and leaving the house did not sound like a clean escape. The episode moves through the rooms slowly. Bumps, bangs, missing items, and shadowy figures begin as the kind of house stuff people try to explain away, until the pattern starts to feel more pointed. Heather is not left alone after frightening nights. After Janet gives birth to twins, Karen and Shannon move into Heather's room, and Heather moves in with Dawn. The porch scene is one of the coldest bits: Jack and Janet hear creaking downstairs, go outside, and find two old rocking chairs moving as if someone is sitting in them. Then they stop dead. The host admits the timeline is hard to lock down, placing that escalation around 1982 or 1983. Prayer does not help either. The family's Catholic routine becomes part of the fear when overpowering bad smells fill the room during prayer. One touch crosses a line. Jack wakes thinking his wife is reaching for him, then finds her asleep and facing the other way. By the end, the host has four forces on the board: a possibly senile presence, a violent young woman, a tall man with a moustache, and a demon. Part one stops while things are still getting worse.

As heard by us

A slow-burn haunting that keeps the house feeling lived in and wrong.

The episode follows the Smurl family haunting as it settles into the life of the house, and that is where it lands best. The narration keeps returning to the ordinary routines around the family, then lets the noises, smells, and moving objects do the work of raising the tension.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

For when you want a haunted-house story that follows a family through 15 years of fear.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Pop culture pedestal podcast