Polyphonic Press - Classic Album Reviews · Jeremy Boyd & Jon VanDyk

Close to You by The Carpenters: Soft-Pop Elegance & Heartbreak

·30 min·2 clips

The second side gets compared to a Grateful Dead jam and a jazz fusion turn.

1. Polyphonic Press reviews Close to You by The Carpenters, focusing on the album’s 1970 release and its soft-pop sound. 2. Jeremy Boyd and John Van Dyke host the episode, and their job is to pick a classic album through the Random Album Generator and then assess it track by track. 3. The episode asks whether Close to You is only polished pop or a record with deeper arrangements and stronger side-two material. 4. The hosts identify the album as the Carpenters’ breakthrough and name Karen Carpenter and Richard Carpenter as the siblings at the center of the project. 5. They describe “They Long to Be Close to You” as the title track, note that Burt Bacharach and Hal David wrote it, and say it won two Grammy Awards. 6. They also call “We’ve Only Just Begun” a wedding standard and mention that it began as a Crocker Bank TV commercial. 7. They say the album was released on August 19, 1970, on A&M Records, and they refer to Jack Daugherty as the producer. 8. The hosts spend time on the first three songs, calling them “too flowery,” “overly sentimental,” and “too syrupy” for their taste. 9. They contrast that reaction with their appreciation for Karen Carpenter’s vocals and Richard Carpenter’s orchestral arranging. 10. They bring up Karen Carpenter as a drummer and say they have seen footage of her playing drums while singing. 11. One recurring point is that the hosts now separate “art” from personal taste, saying music can be valid even when it does not appeal to them. 12. They compare the Carpenters’ style to Barbra Streisand and to what they call the “mellow, soft rock pop stuff” of the 1970s. 13. The discussion of “Help” centers on John Lennon’s reported pride in writing the song and on the hosts’ view that the Carpenters’ version exposes the lyrics’ emotional weight. 14. They say the Beatles were strong at chord movement and pre-chorus writing, and they hear that craft clearly in the Carpenters’ arrangement. 15. The hosts note that Rolling Stone gave the album two and a half stars out of five, which they use as evidence that the record was not a critical darling. 16. They say the title track took over 30 takes to balance Karen’s vocals against the orchestration, and they treat that as proof of how carefully the record was built. 17. They also mention that Richard Carpenter inserted musical nods to Burt Bacharach in the horn and string arrangements, and they say the album helped revive interest in Bacharach-David songs. 18. The tone is conversational and evaluative, with long back-and-forths, repeated second opinions, and a track-by-track format that moves from skepticism to grudging respect. 19. Listeners who like 1970s pop craft and arrangement details. 20. Listeners wanting only a fast verdict on early Carpenters hits.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Polyphonic Press - Classic Album Reviews