Policing Matters · Police1.com

What New York’s 1990s crime drop can teach police today

June 18, 2025·37 min·3 clips
Jack Maple asked NYPD leaders how many shootings occurred last year, and nobody knew—revealing a department not focused on crime.
The frame is practical. Dudley starts with New York's murder numbers: 2,262 in 1990, 671 in 1999, then fewer than 300 in 2017 and 2018. Peter Moskos brings Back from the Brink into the discussion, with the NYPD's 1990s experience as the case study for police dealing with violent crime now. Public space gets real attention. Moskos points to Bryant Park, Dan Biederman, Jane Jacobs, and broken windows as examples of what happens when a place people have written off starts to feel cared for again. The bathroom detail sticks. Flowers in a Bryant Park public restroom become a small but sharp argument for order, maintenance, and pride before the talk drifts into abstract crime strategy. Dudley connects that to CPTED and asks what happens when places are simply let go to pot. The drug comparison stays cautious. Dudley brings up crack's decline and asks whether fentanyl may be following a similar path after national deaths reached 100,000 for the first time in 2020. Moskos does not oversell it. He says it is early, notes that 100,000 deaths is roughly five times the number of murders, and waits on the trend. The policing distinction carries the episode. Drug use, quality-of-life problems, and repeat violent offending all need attention, but Moskos keeps coming back to the point that they cannot be handled the same way. Procedure beats slogan here. This is less nostalgia for 1990s New York than a nuts-and-bolts question: what should police actually do next? The close is easygoing. Dudley jokes that 20 months in Baltimore may equal 20 years elsewhere, then points listeners to the book and asks for their thoughts.

As heard by us

A police-centered take on New York's crime drop, rooted in street-level policy and careful about what the comparison can prove.

Policing Matters frames New York's 1990s murder drop as a practical talk about what changed and what did not. Jim Dudley and Peter Moskos keep returning to the same ground-level concerns: street disorder, repeat violence, takedowns, and the limits of environmental design.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

A former cop-professor's look at New York's extraordinary 1990s crime drop.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on