Philosophy Bites · Edmonds and Warburton

Seth Lazar on Political Philosophy in the Age of AI

September 27, 2023·22 min·2 clips
Seth Lazar reveals how algorithmic systems exercise power over us, from Twitter bans to Google's search dominance.
The conversation starts with a basic question. Lazar says political philosophy has to keep up with major changes in social relations, and AI is one of the new conditions reshaping how people influence one another. Power is the central concern. He argues that AI systems can increase the power held by some actors while making others easier to manipulate, exploit, or deceive, especially when the mediation is diffuse, dispersed, and hard to notice. That is why definition matters. The episode keeps stopping to ask what counts as a legitimate exercise of power, and whether the usual political values are being respected or quietly sidestepped. Liberty stays on the table. So do equality and collective self-determination, which Lazar treats as values that matter a great deal and are not easy to trade away for some promised benefit. He is wary of easy overrides. Even when a system claims to deliver some good, he says there can still be a residual objection that should be removed rather than brushed aside. The goal is not just to knock objections down but to change the way power is exercised so they stop coming up. That leads to recommender systems. Lazar discusses the case for banning them, but he pushes back, saying the deeper issue is that algorithmic intermediaries shape the relations they mediate and therefore need some role in governing those relations. Governance is unavoidable. If those systems do not act conscientiously, he warns, they can end up supporting manipulation, exploitation, and deception rather than helping social life proceed more fairly. Democratic power matters. He points to public regulation in the EU, including the AI Act and digital markets rules, as examples of the kind of institutional response that can begin to answer the problem. Philosophers have work to do. Lazar closes by arguing that the field can be useful if it first learns the terrain and then contributes in a way other disciplines can actually use.

As heard by us

AI here is a power problem, not just a tools problem.

Philosophy Bites treats AI less as a gadget story than as a question of power. Seth Lazar argues that political philosophy needs to update its working model when social relations change, and the discussion stays grounded in ordinary stakes: who has power, how algorithmic…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

For when you want AI framed as a problem of political power, not just a new machine.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on