Pete and Hannah’s Watchlist: · Pete and Hannah Mitchell

AFI Top 100 Movie 99 Toy Story

December 4, 2023·30 min·2 clips
Pete and Hannah review Toy Story, AFI's #99, a film that became his brother's identity through nightly viewings.
1. Pete and Hannah's Watchlist reviews Toy Story, AFI Top 100 number 99, a 1995 Pixar-Disney production. 2. Pete Mitchell hosts alongside co-host Hannah, both regular reviewers of AFI Top 100 titles. 3. The episode asks whether Toy Story is criminally underranked at number 99 and whether it deserved more Oscar recognition in 1995. 4. Pixar began as a Lucasfilm subsidiary before Steve Jobs became chairman and brokered a three-picture deal with Disney, with Toy Story the first film at a $30 million budget. 5. Tom Hanks voiced Woody but was not the first choice — Paul Newman was originally approached, with the cowboy angle matching Newman's later role in Cars. 6. Tim Allen won the Buzz Lightyear role after both Billy Crystal and Jim Carrey declined, believing the project would fail. 7. The first cut portrayed Woody as a dictator who tormented all the toys, not just Buzz, prompting Disney to threaten to reclaim the project; Pixar rebuilt the story and screened a revised cut two weeks later. 8. Test screenings were conducted under the decoy title Operation Dumbo Drop, a Danny Glover film about airlifting an elephant in a war zone, to prevent early word-of-mouth on the real project. 9. Toy Story grossed $353 million worldwide and was the second-highest-grossing film of 1995, behind Die Hard with a Vengeance. 10. At the Academy Awards, Toy Story received a Special Achievement Award for groundbreaking technology but was not nominated for Best Picture; Pete and Hannah argue it deserved a nomination over The Postman and Sense and Sensibility. 11. Randy Newman's You've Got a Friend in Me lost the Best Original Song Oscar to Vanessa Williams' Colours of the Wind from Pocahontas, a result the hosts dispute given the song's lasting cultural presence. 12. Pete frames the film as a buddy cop movie in the Lethal Weapon mould, mapping Woody onto Danny Glover's Roger Murtaugh and Buzz onto the disruptive new partner. 13. The hosts note that Barbie was originally written into Toy Story but Mattel refused to license the character because they expected the film to fail. 14. Don Rickles as Mr. Potato Head and Laurie Metcalf as Andy's mum (later Sheldon's mother in The Big Bang Theory) are highlighted as standout supporting performances. 15. The hosts argue that the film's themes of fear of replacement and self-identity mirror Pixar's own position as new technology displacing Disney's hand-drawn animation tradition. 16. Pete's hot takes include that Woody, not Sid, is the true villain of the film, and that Toy Story 1 is the best entry in the four-film franchise despite Toy Story 3 being an emotional standout. 17. The episode is conversational and informal, with running jokes, toy figurines referenced on screen, and rapid back-and-forth between the two hosts. 18. Energy is enthusiastic but unscripted, with occasional tangents into Disney's current creative struggles and comparisons to other AFI entries. 19. Film buffs interested in behind-the-scenes Hollywood production history and the Disney-Pixar partnership will get the most from this episode. 20. Viewers who want a tight critical analysis rather than a fan-driven conversation with frequent digressions may find the format loose.
Listen to the show on