Pete and Hannah’s Watchlist: · Pete and Hannah Mitchell

AFI Top 100: Movie 97: Yankee Doodle Dandy

December 11, 2023·33 min·2 clips
George M. Cohan's daughter said the movie showed the life her father actually wanted, not his real one.
The AFI list gives them the frame. Pete and Hannah treat Yankee Doodle Dandy like a reason to trade quick movie-history notes, starting with Roosevelt's voice on film. The trivia lands. James Wong Howe comes up because the movie looks great, and his long credit list does some of the work there. Then they get to the line: "My mother thanks you, my father thanks you, my sister thanks you, and I thank you." They know it is famous, and they treat it that way without getting too precious about it. Cagney soon becomes the thing. They trace how James Cagney's George M. Cohan fits against a career full of Public Enemies, Angels with Dirty Faces, The Roaring Twenties, and White Heat. That contrast gives the episode its spark. Pete notes that Cagney got stuck with bad-guy parts even though he came up as a song-and-dance man. Warner Brothers catches some blame for that, especially as they frame this as his last movie with the studio and tie it to executives who saw him too narrowly. Hannah keeps the exchange loose, with little yeses, corrections, and half-thoughts that make it feel like table talk. Jane Leslie gets a real look too: first movie, a dubbed bit, only seventeen, and somehow playing a wide age range. The chemistry sounds questionable, maybe one-sided, but Jane Leslie still comes off as a favorite part of the movie. It stays lively: facts, cast names, reactions, and blunt judgments, without turning the movie into homework.
Listen to the show on