Episode 320: U.S. Demographics and the History of Population Panics

·40 min·3 clips

How did early 20th-century eugenics shape today's white nationalist fears about shrinking birth rates?

The episode begins with host Niki Hemmer introducing the topic of slowing U.S. population growth, noting the impact of COVID-19 and immigration policies. Neil Young discusses the mixed reactions to this trend, highlighting both concerns over recent policies and potential benefits like reduced resource strain. The conversation shifts to historical population panics, referencing Paul Ehrlich's 1968 book 'The Population Bomb' and its focus on resource consumption. Natalia Millman-Pedrozzella connects declining birth rates to racist and white nationalist narratives, citing examples like 'Camp of the Saints' and Charles Murray's work. Neil adds context on early 20th-century eugenics and its progressive origins. The hosts explore the gendered politics of reproduction, contrasting forced sterilization histories with contraception's role in women's agency. They examine how women's delayed childbearing relates to career opportunities and lack of social support, citing survey data on desired family size. Neil explains the Quiverful movement, its scriptural basis, and ties to 1970s conservative fears. The discussion broadens to global issues like China's one-child policy and Malthusian theories on overpopulation. Tensions between population decline concerns and climate change are noted, alongside techno-utopian responses like the Green Revolution. In the closing segment, Natalia announces her new column 'The Quick Study,' analyzing macho marketing in men's skincare. Neil shares a story about flamingo number 492 escaping a Kansas zoo and thriving in Texas. Niki compares Trump's missing insurrection phone logs to Nixon's erased Watergate tapes, emphasizing the cover-up's role in public understanding.

As heard by us

A clear, grounded look at population change as a story about family choices and the conditions around them.

The country's slowest population growth rate on record is treated less as a panic point than as a way into why growth has cooled, and what earlier patterns can and cannot tell us about what comes next.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want population anxiety explained without losing sight of why people delay or forgo children.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Past Present