Passive Real Estate Investing · Real Estate Investing with Marco Santarelli, Investor and Entrepreneur.

Do you really need an LLC before buying your first rental property?

·11 min·1 clip

Melissa Nash reveals why you can't close a conventional loan in an LLC but must for a DSCR loan.

This episode of Passive Real Estate Investing tackles whether new investors must form an LLC before purchasing their first rental property. Host Marco Santorelli introduces the topic, and investor Melissa Nash shares her expertise from building a seven-figure portfolio. They clarify that the answer depends heavily on the type of financing used for the purchase. With a conventional loan, like those from Freddie Mac or Fannie Mae, you cannot close the property directly in an LLC's name. The lender qualifies you personally, and the title must initially be in your personal name. After closing, you can execute a quitclaim deed to transfer the property into an LLC for asset protection. For a DSCR (Debt Service Coverage Ratio) loan, the rules are different, and you are required to close the property directly in the name of an LLC. Melissa Nash emphasizes that LLCs are primarily for asset protection and business organization, not for tax benefits. She shares that attorneys can charge upwards of $10,000 to set up LLC structures for investors. Melissa personally forms her LLCs in Wyoming for under $200 due to the state's affordability, privacy, and business-friendly laws, receiving incorporation documents in under 24 hours. She contrasts this with her home state of California, where LLCs are expensive to form and renew. After forming an LLC, she obtains a free EIN from the IRS and opens a dedicated business bank account using the LLC's documents. She strongly recommends also opening a separate savings account for property reserves to cover vacancies and repairs. Melissa provides a real example of using a quitclaim deed to move a Memphis property bought with a conventional loan into her Wyoming LLC for about $300. For a DSCR loan purchase, her lender required an LLC in the state where the property was located, leading her to quickly form an Arkansas LLC with her Wyoming LLC listed as the owner. A surprising insight is that even with a DSCR loan, some lenders may require a state-specific LLC or a foreign registration, not just any LLC. Melissa's CPA advised that the core value of an LLC is the legal separation it creates between personal and business assets. She believes starting an LLC early fosters a professional, business-minded approach to investing, even if not immediately required by your loan. The tone is educational and conversational, based on personal experience rather than formal legal advice. The style is direct and practical, offering clear steps and real-world examples. This episode is ideal for new real estate investors confused about entity formation and seeking actionable, cost-effective strategies. Listeners looking for deep legal theory or those who have already established their investing entities might find the content too basic.

As heard by us

Clear first-property guidance that ties LLC choice to loan type and basic money separation.

The segment handles the LLC question in a straightforward way, and its main strength is the plain explanation of conventional financing. With standard Freddie/Fannie loans, the property cannot close directly in an LLC, needs to be titled in a personal name, and the borrower is…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want the LLC answer before you buy your first rental.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Passive Real Estate Investing