PAINT BY MURDERS - a Harrisburg Homicide Mystery · M. Travis DiNicola

BOOK CLUBS CAN BE MURDER - Season 3, Episode 4, Chapters 9-11

·26 min·1 clip
Claire explains the club’s written and unwritten rules, then tells the story of Jed, the member they voted out.
Keith has agreed to play detective at book club, which already sounds like a bad fit for his nerves. William gets him into the group, and the gallery turns into a meeting room with folding tables, a tarp, and the ten of them settling in. The food arrives first: cheese, fruit, salads, rice pilaf, Brussels sprouts, soup, and apple pudding cake. Helpful for dinner, less helpful for murder. William is late, so Keith waits while the women drift into gossip, drinks, and the kind of chatter that almost feels normal until Desmond's death comes back into focus. Even the movie argument refuses to stay simple. Susan, Phoebe, and Pearl pick apart whether a foreign film really happened or was taking place inside a squirrel's mind. Deanne tells Claire about trouble at the dog park. Harmony and Cynthia listen while Linda praises bourbon aged in Pinot Noir casks. Keith mostly listens and eats, which is a problem, because the food is easier to track than the suspects. Then the door buzzes. William arrives, and Keith drags him aside like a man whose notes have turned against him. The descriptions are no good. Phoebe talks too much, nobody looks their age, and Cynthia and Susan are somehow impossible to keep straight. Keith calls himself a horrible detective, and honestly, the panic is the fun of it. The clues are tucked inside regular talk, not big confessions. By the end, Harmony helps without meaning to. Her embarrassed guess about Ted's big announcement gives Keith a small detail that starts changing how the room looks.

As heard by us

A gallery book club turns into a clue hunt full of food, gossip, and awkward suspect confusion.

This installment turns a murder hunt into gossip, food, and the slow sorting of who knows what about Desmond. Keith keeps trying to pin people down, but the scene keeps drifting from a foreign movie the group cannot even agree on to a difficult puppy and bourbon aged in Pinot…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

When the suspect list gets tangled, the wine and chatter start doing the detective work.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on