Episode #239 - Did a Welsh Prince Beat Columbus to the New World?

November 18, 2025·1 hr 16 min·5 clips

Why would indigenous people in Virginia use a Welsh word for a white-headed bird called a penguin?

Start with a stranded crew. David Ingram, Richard Brown, and Richard Twyde are put ashore after John Hawkins' battered Minion escapes Spanish warships and runs aground on the west coast of Florida. Not exactly solid footing. That odd survival story gives the host a way into another ocean-crossing tale: the one tied to the Welsh prince Madoc. The evidence does not rush in. Medieval Welsh poetry gives us a Maedoc, but the references are too thin to make him the seafaring hero. Names can fool people. Maedoc was common enough in medieval Wales that the poems do not point cleanly to one historical prince. Then there is the lost romance. A 13th-century Flemish work, known only through scattered references, seems to put a Welsh Madoc on an island paradise. Tempting, sure. But the source is gone, and the scraps left behind do not say much beyond love, music, Wales, and a voyage. Two centuries later, a poem from around the 1470s finally connects more of the pieces: a seafaring Madoc and King Owain. Here is the problem. By the host's count, that lands roughly 300 years after Madoc allegedly reached North America, which is not contemporary evidence. The legend keeps getting bigger. Elizabethan writers later reshape it into a pro-empire tale. The verdict is plain. Before those late-1500s retellings, the documentary case for Prince Madoc's voyage is basically nonexistent.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Our Fake History