Episode #235 - Was The Parthenon Robbed? (Part II)

September 23, 2025·1 hr 28 min·5 clips

Lord Elgin lost his fortune, reputation, wife, and half his nose after taking Parthenon sculptures—was it Athena's curse?

Some artifacts come with a curse. The host starts with the kind of archaeological bad luck that is almost too fun to resist, putting the Parthenon marbles beside King Tut, the sarcophagus that allegedly sank the Titanic, and the Spear of Destiny. Elgin fits right in. After his workmen took some of the best preserved sculptures from the Parthenon, his life starts to read like a punishment story. Carl Meyer gives the episode its sharpest summary of the damage: Elgin's time in Constantinople gets linked to the loss of fortune, reputation, wife, and the lower half of his nose. Coincidence, probably. But Athena as judge is a cleaner story. The curse gives the episode a way into the older fight over who should have the marbles. The Greeks had asked before. After the 1844 request, the argument seems to go quiet for decades, with the marbles still in London and the anger waiting for better language. Frederick Harrison supplies it in 1890 with Give Back the Elgin Marbles. His piece shifts the question from whether Elgin should have taken them to whether Britain should keep them. Harrison's point is simple and hard to shake: these are not freestanding statues. They are parts of a famous ruined building that is still there, still carrying national meaning. A visitor to the Acropolis sees plaster where originals should be, a caryatid swapped for a cast, and pediments scarred by Elgin's removals. The split becomes the injury. The host keeps the tone dry, so the episode never turns into a lecture. It ends up as a messier and better story about curses, damage, memory, and return.

As heard by us

A thoughtful look at the Parthenon marbles, the curse rumor around them, and the case for returning them.

This episode frames the Parthenon marbles as both a curse tale and a removal dispute, which suits the show’s habit of pairing history with legend.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want the Parthenon marbles story with the curse rumor left in the room.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Our Fake History