Bonus Episode - Helots, Spartan Women, and Historical Fiction

May 13, 2025·39 min·3 clips

Thucydides describes how Spartans tricked 2,000 helots into claiming freedom, then made them all disappear.

Spartan slaves come first. Sebastian Major opens the bonus format by stepping outside the usual myth busting structure for a tighter listener feedback episode tied to a series. It is still Our Fake History, with the same question hanging around: what is fact, what is fiction, and what is too good to stop talking about? Then the episode turns grim. The focus shifts to the helots, the enslaved population whose suffering ancient writers describe again and again. He keeps the comparison careful. Instead of turning helotage and the Atlantic slave trade into one blunt ranking, he points out that conditions changed by colony, Caribbean island, region, and period. Ancient sources need handling with care. Thucydides may be biased, and the host repeats his usual warning that numbers in ancient texts should not be swallowed whole. Still, the pattern matters. When several classical sources describe Spartan treatment as cruel and bitter, he argues that the broad conclusion carries weight. The comparison stays narrow on purpose. He gives listeners a baseline for Sparta, then nudges them toward Haiti, the American South, Brazil, or any other specific case before making sharper claims. The bonus episode is chatty at the edges, with housekeeping about throwbacks and audience questions, but the history stays careful. Spartan women and historical fiction sit on the larger agenda. The strongest material is the helot discussion, where moral clarity sits beside real caution. No tidy ranking arrives. The point is simpler: comparison only works when the evidence stays specific.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Our Fake History