Original Gangsters Podcast · Original Gangsters, a True Crime Talk Podcast

Operation Gametax: The Case That Crippled The Detroit Crime Family

·1 hr 32 min·4 clips
Both the podcast and the Patreon members only—this is the start of a series where we get people from opposite ends of a legal conflict or mob war and hash out stuff that happened back in the day.
Scott Bernstein opens the show by calling it a very special edition. He says it is the start of a series built around putting people from opposite sides of a legal conflict, or a mob war, at the same table after decades apart. The first test case is the 1996 Operation Game Tax prosecution. Bernstein describes that case as the biggest prosecution of the Detroit Mafia in the history of the Toco early crime family. Novi Toco joins as the former member of the family who was convicted in it. Rick Convertino joins as the prosecutor who put him away. Bernstein notes that the two have not seen each other in 30 years and that this is the first time they have been in the same room since Toco's conviction back in 1998. The conversation starts with Convertino being asked to lay out the background and explain how he got involved. The setup is less about a tidy recap than about letting the record come out in the room. From there the talk turns into a broader look at Detroit underworld politics. One strand centers on Pete Covettile and why he became a target. The discussion weighs the idea that Dominic Corrado's death opened the door, while also noting that Corrado had already become very ill. Bernstein pushes the idea that Covettile's drug business changed the equation. The episode leans on the money trail, the stash, and the way word of that stash spread. It also follows who Covettile was doing business with, including non-Italian partners and others in the trade. Bernstein says he does not believe in coincidences. The conversation then reaches the killing itself and the grand jury testimony that named some bigger players. That makes the case sound less like a tight, small Detroit job and more like a wider conspiracy. The episode closes by widening the frame again, with Bernstein talking about another slow negotiation for a future sit-down involving the Boston group. He also points listeners toward the Patreon, the podcast, YouTube, iTunes, and Spotify for more material.

As heard by us

A Detroit mob reckoning built on memory, motive, and still-disputed details.

The episode brings Scott Bernstein, former Detroit Mafia member Novi Toco, and prosecutor Rick Convertino to the same table to revisit the 1996 Operation Game Tax case, described here as the biggest prosecution of the Detroit Mafia in the history of the Toco family.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want the prosecutor and the mob guy in the same room after 30 years.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on