One Life One Chance with Toby Morse

Ian Fidance Part 2 (comedian)

·1 hr 39 min·5 clips
Comedian Ian Fidance cried in his car after singing with H2O, a moment he calls 'the coolest'.
Toby opens by thanking the listeners who have kept the podcast going for the past six years. He explains why the show remains audio-only and free. The kitchen is part of the point. Without lights or cameras, guests can settle in and talk honestly. He also refuses to break up the conversation with midroll ads, saying sponsors keep the show running without wrecking its rhythm. Once the conversation finds its groove, things get loose, blunt and personal. A story about being heartbroken by an admired performer gives way to an uncomfortable truth: performers are regular people dealing with real problems. That feeling steers the conversation toward music. Toby's guest ties his reaction to the blunt honesty he found in hardcore and punk rock. Those scenes gave him an ethos he still lives by, and he feels permanently indebted to hardcore music. Ska has its hooks in him too, for better or worse. He has played in a ska band, wears a ska ring and talks about the genre without a hint of embarrassment. That open enthusiasm brought him into the ska community for a while. It also leaves him with strong opinions about who gets to reshape a scene. He wants people welcomed, but believes an established culture is allowed to have boundaries. Newcomers should learn the history and find their footing before demanding that the community change around them. He brings the same thinking to violence in hardcore and old band logos that rub against newer expectations. The episode closes with Toby asking listeners dealing with addiction or sobriety to contact a confidential recovery service, and reminding them that people care about them and want them here.

As heard by us

A candid kitchen-table conversation about punk gratitude, ska loyalty and whether newcomers should adapt before reshaping a scene.

Toby and his guest talk through the loyalties built around punk, hardcore and ska, along with the responsibility of stepping into a scene that already has its own history. The episode finds its footing in gratitude.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play for a kitchen-table clash between all-are-welcome idealism and old-scene loyalty.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on