Old Capital Real Estate Investing Podcast with Michael Becker & Paul Peebles · Michael Becker & Paul Peebles

EPS 340 - Are Today's "Humpty Dumpty" B & C Apartment Deals Falling Apart? Can You Put Them Back Together?

·41 min·2 clips
Brian Amos says hail deductibles rose from $25,000 to $100,000 or 2% to 5%, leaving roof damage unclaimed.
1. The Old Capital Real Estate Investing Podcast, Episode 340, examines why physical condition and deferred maintenance on B and C apartment deals matter after roughly two years of falling multifamily values. 2. Paul Peebles, Old Capital's National Underwriter, hosts solo because Michael Becker is on a due diligence assignment, and he interviews Brian Amos of Omni Group in the Dallas-Fort Worth area. 3. Amos, an engineer who spent 10 years in a cubicle before starting physical assessments in 2009, says he has reviewed nearly 100,000 units worth a couple of billion dollars, and that the market now resembles the post-Great Recession years. 4. Peebles contrasts the 2012-2013 period, when each new owner put $3,000 to $5,000 per unit into upgrades every few years, with the last two to three years, when 550 basis points of rate increases sent cash to debt service instead. 5. Amos cites a recently sold late-1970s property where a roof leak was fixed but the unit damage was not, leaving mold that now needs remediation, and he recommends scoping plumbing lines because cast iron lasts about 50 years versus 100 for PVC. 6. He explains that Federal Pacific panels from the 1980s were once accepted by lenders but now must be replaced, and that his team walks 97% of units on average with a 90-point checklist and a 1-to-5 grading scale. 7. On roofs, Amos says hail deductibles in North Texas moved from $25,000 to $100,000 or 2% to 5%, that 25% of the properties he inspected for free had hail damage, and that it cannot be seen from the ground. 8. Peebles notes that a $5,000 new property condition assessment can be triggered years after closing, and that Fannie Mae's March 2025 rule change on Federal Pacific panels means "it's not 2019, it's 2026." 9. Amos describes one client whose lender's assessment found over $1 million in deferred maintenance, which his team challenged with actual bids, a structural engineer, and pictures, saying that accurate bids "always beat an estimate from a table." 10. Suited to multifamily buyers and syndicators weighing due diligence on older apartment properties.
Listen to the show on