Obscura: A True Crime Podcast · Justin Drown

MURDERED: Jessica Lunsford (Part 2 of 2) | Homosassa, FL 2005

November 18, 2025·29 min

Obscura Episode: Jessica Lunsford (Part 2 of 2). Host Joe Winko presents the second part of Jessica Lunsford's 2005 murder case from Citrus County, Florida. Opening with a respectful visit to Jessica's grave, Winko establishes victim-centered framing. The episode details the forensic investigation revealing Jessica was kidnapped from her home, held for three days, sexually assaulted by John Cooey, then buried alive in garbage bags with her stuffed purple dolphin. Medical evidence shows decomposition consistent with three weeks underground, shallow lacerations indicating sexual trauma, and critically, thrashing marks in the trash bags revealing she was conscious during burial. Cooey's confession reveals premeditation (hole already dug, escape ladder built) contradicting his 'impulse' claim. Despite overwhelming evidence and his own admission, Cooey showed no remorse, only self-pity about his own incarceration. Host Winko deliberately excludes Cooey's minimizing narrative, presenting instead a clear forensic narrative centered on Jessica's humanity and the crime's brutality.

As heard by us

A grave-side opening leads into Jessica Lunsford's murder, then toward the community and advocacy shaped by her legacy.

Obscura opens this single-episode review of Jessica Lunsford's case at her grave in Citrus County, Florida, then follows the story into planning, concealment, and burial.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You press play when a graveside visit opens onto Jessica Lunsford's 2005 murder and the work built in her memory.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify