Obscura: A True Crime Podcast · Justin Drown

MURDERED: Heather Strong (Part 1 of 2) | Marion County, FL 2009

January 20, 2026·48 min·3 clips

A love triangle in rural Florida turned deadly — and the line between devotion and destruction was thinner than anyone imagined.

Obscura begins by placing Heather Strong’s story in the shadows of rural Florida. It treats the case as a betrayal that pulls ordinary people into a grim sequence of deception and loss. The episode focuses on Heather, Joshua Fulgham, and Amelia Carr, with their relationship as the unstable core of the tragedy. The narration opens with a grave warning, then drops straight into the blunt friction of a recorded interview. The interviewer keeps pressing for clarity. The witness keeps pushing back. That back-and-forth becomes the engine of the episode. The questions circle arguments, distance, and threats of violence. The recording raises claims about a hair-pulling incident and a knife being held to Heather’s throat. The witness denies those details, and the denial only sharpens the tension. The episode does not try to smooth the contradictions away. It keeps returning to hesitation, partial answers, and the sense that everyone is protecting something. Around those exchanges, the narration widens the frame to the children, the shared living situation, and the messy fallout of a relationship that has stopped behaving like one. It shows how quickly private conflict can turn into public evidence. It also makes room for the awkward strain of official questioning. The language stays controlled, but the material does not. The episode moves with a steady, unsparing pace through motive, confession, and mutual blame. It is interested in the emotional damage as much as the case mechanics. Near the end, Acom leaves, and when he returns later that morning, Heather and the children are gone. A phone call follows, and Joshua says he and Heather have reconciled. That claim changes the shape of what comes next. The episode ends by making one thing clear: this is still the beginning of the tragedy, not the end of it. The final note is dread, not resolution. This episode closes with the betrayal fully in view and the murder still ahead.

As heard by us

A grim, source-led love-triangle story that turns betrayal into a slow account of harm.

Heather Strong's story is laid out as a rural Florida love triangle that ends in death, with Heather Strong, Joshua Fulgham, and Amelia Carr at the center of betrayal, heartbreak, and loss.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play if you want the case to unfold through pressure, denial, and interrogation audio.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Obscura: A True Crime Podcast