Plantagenet vs. Tudor: Who was the Rightful King?

March 23, 2026·59 min·5 clips

When Henry Tudor seized the crown in 1485, 18 Plantagenet descendants had stronger claims—so who was the rightful king?

The Tudor settlement feels uneasy here. Henry is shown as loving his mother, and that affection leaves him more willing to use Yorkist legitimacy than Henry VII had been. Margaret rises first. She becomes Countess of Salisbury in her own right, restored to a title and position tied to her family. The honour does not stay harmless. Later in the reign, Henry comes to see that family as dangerous, and Margaret, already in her sixties, pays the ultimate price. Catherine sits at the edge of the discussion. The host asks whether Catherine of Aragon helped shape Henry's comfort with a woman holding that kind of power, since Spain offered a different model. Then the question opens out again. Edmund appears as the younger brother of John, which makes him another plausible Yorkist claimant after John is gone. William and Richard are there too, part of a family that had not clearly rebelled against Tudor government. That makes the break sharper. The guest stresses that their father was not involved in the rebellions, and that the brothers did not seem suspicious at first. Then comes the jolt. Around 1501 or 1502, close to Prince Arthur's death and after the executions of Perkin Warbeck and the Earl of Warwick, Edmund and Richard leave England for the continent. At Maximilian's court in the Holy Roman Empire, Edmund starts calling himself Duke of Suffolk. He also takes up the White Rose, presenting himself as the rightful Yorkist heir to England. The point lands quietly: a claim to the throne can sleep for years, then wake up when politics gives it room.

As heard by us

A sharp, measured look at Tudor legitimacy and the Yorkist claim.

This episode treats Tudor legitimacy as a live political problem rather than a settled fact, and that framing gives it real momentum. It moves neatly through Margaret Countess of Salisbury, Edmund de la Pole, and the wider Yorkist family, showing how Tudor power could lean…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Follow the Tudor succession dispute through the Yorkist claimants it worried most.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Not Just the Tudors