Not Just Cute, the Podcast: Intentional Whole Child Development for Parents and Teachers of Young Children · Amanda Morgan

Episode 84: The Essential Role of Agency in Play and Early Learning

March 3, 2026·29 min
Agency comes first in this episode. Amanda Morgan says play rests on agency and joy, then spends the hour asking what agency means in an early childhood program. She does not pretend to wrap the whole subject up neatly. Instead, she follows the useful threads: motivation, self-regulation, learning, and the feel of real play. The toy-choice example lands well. A 2025 study from the Early Childhood Education Journal found that children stayed longer with toys they helped choose than with similar toys that were simply handed to them with instructions to play. It is a small classroom moment with a bigger point behind it. Children are not just reacting to materials. When they get some say, they bring direction, interest, and ownership to the play. Morgan keeps separating genuine play from activities that merely look playful. A lesson can have bright materials, cheerful prompts, and playful language, but if the child has little room to decide, the agency is thin. That is where the episode gets a little bracing. Without agency, the surface of play may still be there, but the stronger stuff underneath starts to fade. The concern then widens. Morgan draws on research connected to Dr. Peter Gray to link shrinking agency with mental health concerns for children, while noting that the book takes that argument further. She also uses the image of pulling a thread from a tapestry: remove developmentally appropriate agency, and other parts of development can start to snag. Her phrase for the obstacle is pervasive passivity. It describes a culture that keeps nudging young children out of active engagement and into being entertained, distracted, managed, or offered choices that are barely choices. The episode stays practical, though. Morgan asks teachers and parents to look at their own programs and routines. Where are adults choosing too much? Where are screens or prescribed activities taking over the child's authorship? The point is simple enough to defend: children's choices and intentions are not extras. They are part of how early learning gets its force.

As heard by us

A clear, grounded case for treating children's choices as essential to powerful play.

Agency gives the episode its spine: the power of a child's choice sits at the center of meaningful play and early learning. Amanda Morgan ties that idea to motivation and self-regulation, then grounds it in a 2025 Early Childhood Education Journal study showing that children…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Want to understand why a child-chosen toy can hold attention longer?

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on