Not Another Military History Podcast · Jakob Sibley

The Seminole Wars, Part 2: The Swamp is Speaking Seminole

·48 min·3 clips

Jackson orders removal by force if necessary after the Seminoles reject the treaty demands.

Jacob picks back up after the First Seminole War. He opens on the aftermath of Andrew Jackson's Florida mess, where Jackson had already burned villages, clashed with Spanish installations, executed British subjects, and left behind a diplomatic headache without proper authorization. The U.S. gets nervous. Britain is still a serious power, so the episode shows why Jackson's stunt could have turned into a much bigger problem than a quick victory and march away. Then comes the treaty fight. Seminole leaders return with a different story, denying that they signed freely or saying that they were forced, and insisting that they were never meant to bind the whole nation because the agreement was supposed to go back to the chiefs for a broader decision. The word they becomes the whole fight. The U.S. reads the agreement as the chiefs speaking for everyone, while the Seminole reading treats the chiefs as messengers who would report back before any final move. That is not a small disagreement. It is the kind of difference that decides whether an entire people is being asked, or simply pushed. The translation situation makes it uglier. The interpreters were Abraham and Kudjo, two Black men who were themselves illiterate and only knew the language of the plantation, which is about as sturdy a bridge as a soggy plank over a swamp. Slavery sits right underneath all of it. For the Seminoles, mixed people could still count as Indian, but white Americans treated any Black blood as grounds for slavery, so the treaty argument and the identity argument kept grinding into each other. The episode does not stay in abstraction. It keeps moving toward the next military shove, with Major Pierce sent to shut down Fort Defiance. Pierce ends up in an inconclusive battle with Osceola. Osceola gets back into the swamp, and by the end of the month Fort Defiance is shut down with central Florida in Seminole hands. That is where the episode stops. The war is still very much alive, and the swamp is still doing most of the talking.

As heard by us

A Seminole Wars episode centered on treaty language, translation, and slavery.

This episode picks up after the First Seminole War and stays with the political trouble that followed Andrew Jackson's actions in Florida. Its strongest section is the treaty dispute: who the agreement was meant to bind, what "they" referred to, and how that small point reshaped…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

When treaty words go bad, the swamp becomes the battlefield you can't ignore.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Not Another Military History Podcast