Not Another Football Podcast | Weekly Premier League Podcast · Not Another Football Podcast

Liverpool & Chelsea’s Ultimate Combined Premier League XI – Who Makes the Cut? ⚽🔥

March 25, 2025·23 min

Luke and Oli open by pointing out that there is no Premier League action that week, so they turn the break into a Liverpool and Chelsea combined all-time XI. Simple enough. They agree on 4-3-3, then move straight into the toughest calls, with goalkeeper the first real dividing line and Alisson firmly in Luke's corner. Petr Cech is the other name in the mix. Luke backs Alisson as the best Premier League keeper of all time, leaning on an all-round game he rates above Cech and Peter Schmeichel. Oli does not push that argument too far. The episode then shifts into the forward debate, where Hazard, Suarez, Salah, and Drogba all sit inside the conversation and nobody gets an easy route through. That is where it gets lively. Salah's numbers and consistency carry real weight, and the hosts keep coming back to the scale of what he has done across seasons. Suarez still sounds like the player who bends the whole debate. They keep returning to how he nearly dragged Liverpool to a title on his own, and the way they frame those years feels grounded in what they watched rather than nostalgia. Sturridge, Coutinho, and Gerrard hover around that Liverpool case in the background. Hazard gets a similar treatment, with the show recalling how often Chelsea's attack ran through him and how that spell sat inside a stronger squad. Mourinho's return hangs over that side of the discussion. The episode keeps moving between peak ability and longevity, which is really the central problem with building an all-time XI across two clubs. That question never quite goes away. The hosts also let the football-room shorthand do some work, so the chat feels like two people who watched these seasons live and are still trying to settle them. It closes by asking listeners to send in their own combined XI and their team of the season per club. There is also a quick nod to next week, when Premier League talk returns after the international break. For anyone who likes club-tinged arguments about legends, this sits right in that lane.

As heard by us

A Liverpool-Chelsea XI debate that sharpens around peak form, longevity, and a few huge calls.

The episode uses a Premier League-free week to shape a combined Liverpool and Chelsea all-time XI, settling on a 4-3-3 before the main calls begin.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If you want a Liverpool-vs-Chelsea chat that turns into a fiery all-time Premier League XI debate, press play tonight.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify