Scripting the Flip - Christmas - The Outsider is Now the Insider

·37 min·3 clips

Pastor Josh reads a Christmas verse about Herod killing babies, asking what makes someone good or bad.

This episode is a Christmas sermon from Northwest Hills Community Church, delivered by lead pastor Josh Karstensen. It continues a series in Matthew chapter 2, focusing on the reactions of Herod and the wise men to Jesus' birth. The host opens by reading Matthew 2:16, which describes Herod killing infants, and poses the question of what makes someone good or bad. He then tells a detailed, fabricated backstory for Herod, highlighting his traumatic upbringing as an outsider, abusive father, and experiences of war, to humanize him. After revealing the fabrication, Karstensen critiques contemporary culture's tendency to sympathize with villains through backstories, citing examples like the Joker, Darth Vader, and the Grinch. He argues this leads to moral relativism, where actions are seen as merely products of environment. The sermon shifts to the wise men, describing them as social elites from Babylon who traveled 800 miles to worship Jesus. Karstensen connects their journey to the prophecy in Daniel 2, where Daniel interprets Nebuchadnezzar's dream about a stone destroying earthly kingdoms and establishing an eternal one. He posits that the wise men were seeking this absolute, divine truth in Jesus. In contrast, Herod is depicted as threatened by Jesus, leading to his violent actions. The host asserts that despite motives or upbringing, actions like killing babies are wrong because they violate God's standard. He emphasizes that all people are sinners held responsible for their choices, but Jesus came to pay for that sin through his birth and death. The conclusion invites listeners to respond with the wise men's joy, accepting forgiveness and letting go of shame. The format is a solo sermon with narrative elements, blending biblical exegesis with cultural commentary.

As heard by us

Matthew 2 becomes a clear study of worship, resistance, and forgiveness.

Josh Karstensen's Christmas message in Matthew 2 sets grief and joy side by side, then turns to Herod and the wise men to show how differently people can respond when truth arrives.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If Christmas sermons feel too gentle, this one starts with Herod and a star.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Northwest Hills Community Church