Normalizing Non-Monogamy - Personal Stories of Polyamory, Swinging, and Beyond · Emma and Fin

Ep 433 - Cyndee + Mitch

·1 hr 14 min·5 clips

Mitch and Cyndee were arrested for lewd behavior on a beach after years of secret exhibitionism.

This episode features hosts Finn and Emma interviewing long-term married couple Cyndee and Mitch about their journey into non-monogamy. Mitch is a relationship coach with Expansive Connection, and the couple has been together for decades, officially opening their relationship in 2022. Their exploration began with nudism, seeking secluded beaches for topless sunbathing and eventually visiting a nude resort in Jamaica decades ago. A pivotal moment occurred when they were caught by park rangers and ticketed for "lewd behavior" after having sex on a public beach, which pushed them to seek designated lifestyle spaces. They attended a Bliss Cruise and returned to Hedonism resort, where they met podcasters from Casual Swinger and recorded an episode about their background as former pastors. At Hedonism, an unexpected situation arose when another woman showed interest in Mitch, which Cyndee had not anticipated and found traumatic. The couple spent about two years working through this incident with podcasts, books, and counseling before progressing from parallel play to soft swap and then full swap. They describe their current approach as "swally," seeking long-term friendships with other couples where sexual play is a possible bonus but not the sole focus. An interesting insight is how a negative legal experience directly motivated them to find communities where their desired behaviors were accepted. Mitch shares a humorous future wish for a burlesque dancer friend to perform at his funeral to surprise their "vanilla" friends. The couple emphasizes that early on, they lacked the vocabulary and resources now available to discuss non-monogamy, which made navigating new desires challenging. Their story highlights that shifting from merely accepting others' non-monogamy to embracing it for themselves required significant internal work. The tone is conversational and reflective, with guests sharing personal anecdotes and lessons learned over decades. This episode would appeal to listeners interested in long-term relationship evolution, the intersection of religion and sexuality, and slow, intentional paths into non-monogamy. Those seeking only fast-paced stories or strictly polyamorous content might find less relevance.

As heard by us

A beach arrest becomes a candid, warm look at exhibitionism and non-monogamous freedom.

The episode opens with a beach encounter that ends in an arrest for lewd behavior, then broadens into a frank look at exhibitionism, caution, and the freedom the couple finds in a more lifestyle-adjacent way of relating.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

A beach arrest becomes a surprisingly warm story about non-monogamy and community.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Normalizing Non-Monogamy - Personal Stories of Polyamory, Swinging, and Beyond