Nonprofit Leadership Podcast · Dr. Rob Harter

The Biggest Fundraising Challenges Facing the Social Impact Sector

·33 min·2 clips

Jenna Lynch argues donors aren't tired of giving; they're tired of giving without understanding the meaning behind it.

1. The Nonprofit Leadership Podcast episode 'The Biggest Fundraising Challenges Facing the Social Impact Sector' covers 2025 fundraising trends and expectations for 2026, with a focus on donor retention and AI. 2. Host Dr. Rob Harder talks with Jenna Lynch of Donorbox, a podcast sponsor, who co-hosts her own nonprofit show and attends conferences across the country. 3. Lynch's thesis is that relying on trends is 'not exactly sustainable,' and that the real shift is a mindset move away from reactive fundraising toward revenue leaders can control. 4. She says leaders are anchoring on individual and recurring donors after delayed government funding and lost grants, citing executive directors who say a 10% increase in donors would let them 'finally be able to plan next year without guessing.' 5. Harder describes a friend's event that beat its goal by 10% or 20% while the number of givers fell, and Lynch calls this 'the paradox of the sector' and says leaders respond with intentional first-year donor experiences and segmented donor journeys. 6. Lynch, a Millennial, says her generation is 'discerning,' wants transparency and participation through volunteering and advocacy, and that co-creation increases loyalty and word of mouth, while the great generational wealth transfer makes legacy-giving conversations timely. 7. She calls donor fatigue 'misdiagnosed,' saying donors are 'tired of giving without understanding the meaning behind it,' and recommends in-progress updates, including emails that are lowercase and unpolished, with gratitude built into the culture. 8. Both hosts stress communication: Lynch warns that 'silence creates doubt' when organizations skip updates because the news is not exciting, and suggests simply saying progress is 'steady, but slow.' 9. On AI, Lynch describes a 'quiet behind the scenes partner' that cleans donor data and drafts first versions of impact reports, getting work '70% of the way done in minutes,' and says she has never paid for an AI tool but would invest in a CRM's built-in assistant. 10. Suited to nonprofit fundraisers, executive directors, and development staff weighing donor retention and AI.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Nonprofit Leadership Podcast