NFL Daily with Gregg Rosenthal

Power Players: Patriots director of pro personnel A.J. Highsmith

·25 min·2 clips
Patriots director A.J. Highsmith reveals how being 'raised by football' shaped his scouting career from age nine.
A.J. Highsmith's interest in scouting began with watching Alonzo Highsmith work. The conversation carries that influence through A.J.'s own playing experience, including at the University of Miami, and into personnel roles with the San Francisco 49ers, the Titans, the Bills, and the New England Patriots. He now serves as the New England Patriots' pro personnel director. The host asks how the football calendar fits together. Highsmith describes a season that can run all the way through the Super Bowl before the next stages of evaluation and free agency fully come into focus. His first experience going that deep into an extended season gave him a sharper view of the process. He remembers the logistical strain of evaluating potential free agents while preparing for the Super Bowl. The work asks people to keep several threads moving at once, with football preparation and personnel decisions sharing the same calendar. Highsmith says the most obvious talents are only the simplest part of the evaluation. He points to long meetings, collaboration with coaches, and the many opinions that feed into a decision. A player has to be studied through more than whether he can help. Highsmith uses buying a house to explain the deeper investigation. The comparison brings in background, history, circumstances, who built the house, and how long it might last. He applies the same thinking to a player's place on a team now and over time. The conversation moves from spotting talent toward fit and team construction. The closing discussion returns to complementary traits. Highsmith considers how those traits can be built within a roster, a side of the ball, and different position groups. The host also highlights his question about trying to get tougher. That question opens a wider thought about finding another way to read a player's story when traits or measurables seem to point one way. The episode leaves personnel work rooted in patient questions, shared evaluation, and the search for how each piece can strengthen the whole.

As heard by us

A.J. Highsmith gives the NFL personnel calendar and player-evaluation process a clear, practical shape.

Building an NFL roster comes across as a patient test of judgment, not a simple hunt for obvious talent. A.J. Highsmith, the New England Patriots' pro personnel director, grounds that idea in his own path, from watching his father, Alonzo Highsmith, scout and help build teams to…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You get a front-office tour where a house-buying metaphor explains why player evaluation takes so much work.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on