NewOrleans.Football: Saints Podcast · NewOrleans.Football

Full Episode: Do the Saints have a top-12 quarterback situation in the NFL?

·52 min·4 clips
Nick Underhill argues Josh Allen's fumble before halftime doomed the Bills' Super Bowl hopes.
The show opens on one clean question: where does the quarterback picture in the NFL sit right now? That quickly turns into a broader ranking exercise, because the hosts start comparing quarterbacks by age, contract, mileage left, and what a team can still build around them instead of just name value. Bo Nix comes up early. His rookie contract becomes part of the argument, since the show keeps coming back to how much easier it is to like a young quarterback when you are not also carrying a huge veteran salary. Brock Purdy is next. One host puts Purdy around the back end of the top 12, while also noting that the question changes once you start asking who you would rather have for the next few years, not just who looked best last season. Justin Herbert and Dak Prescott are in the mix. From there, the board gets messier, because the conversation is no longer about who is clearly elite and more about who sits in that murky range where contracts, injuries, and future flexibility matter almost as much as pure play. Jordan Love gets a real look. Trevor Lawrence, Jared Goff, Baker Mayfield, and Jalen Hurts all follow, and the show keeps weighing age against mileage, upside against certainty, and what kind of offense each quarterback lets a team keep running. Lamar Jackson gets added higher up. Once he is on the board, the discussion starts to feel like a real sorting exercise, with the hosts trying to pin down where the breakpoints actually are and which names still belong in a tier above the rest. The rookies are not left out. Jackson Dart, Shuck, and Cam Ward come into the conversation when the show turns to where first-year quarterbacks fit once the league starts separating the promising from the proven. CJ Stroud becomes another checkpoint. The hosts ask how far he has fallen, whether he can climb back up, and how he compares with Bryce Young and Kyler Murray once you stop talking in slogans and start talking in football terms. Then the episode shifts gears. The back half moves into a Saints-related note about Ted Rath and a long list of things the team is trying to get right, with the hosts drawing a line between problems that are hard to control and problems that can actually be fixed if the team keeps paying attention. That part matters. It lands as one more sign that the Saints are trying to sort out the issues they can fix, check the boxes, and keep the season pointed in a better direction.

As heard by us

A Saints quarterback debate that broadens into a sharp check on value and team building.

This episode starts with a Saints question and keeps widening the frame until it becomes a useful quarterback value debate. The hosts move through rookie deals, veteran money, and the different ways teams justify paying for the position, touching Bo Nix, Purdy, Herbert, Dak,…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a Saints-adjacent quarterback debate that turns into a league-wide ranking exercise.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on