New Game Plus - A Retro Gaming Podcast · New Game Plus

Episode 475: Where in the World Is Carmen Sandiego?

·1 hr 5 min·5 clips
Carmen Sandiego wasn't designed as edutainment—it stumbled into teaching geography by accident.
The show starts with a Rockapella joke, then slides into the kind of loose banter New Game Plus runs on. They introduce the episode, remind listeners that this is episode 475, and pose the week’s question: if you had to replace the number in a video game title with a subtitle, what would it be? That opens the door to the usual split between serious, silly, and just plain odd answers, plus a few attempts to come up with something that actually sounds like a real title. The game becomes the main topic once the joking settles down. The hosts treat it as edutainment and talk about how the game teaches by making you solve things while you play. They compare it to studying for a test: repetition helps the facts stay put, and the game backs that up with short visual cues, like a flag, a currency, or a quick image of the place you are supposed to be thinking about. The conversation keeps circling back to how well that structure works. One host says adult geography knowledge is pretty rusty and that fourth grade knowledge probably lasted longer than current memory. That is part of the point: the game may not turn anyone into a specialist, but it gets information into players’ heads. They also note that earlier versions of this kind of educational game were built to send players back to the almanac or textbook, which makes the whole thing feel very old school in how it teaches. They spend time on the progression system too, where successful missions let you rank up from rookie to sleuth to private eye to investigator. That gives the game some forward motion on top of the clue chasing loop. The hosts clearly respect that design, and the discussion keeps shifting between nostalgia and a practical question: did the game teach first, or did the teaching become part of the game by design? The answer lands somewhere close to both. The episode stays relaxed and conversational throughout. There are corrections, interruptions, and the usual side chatter, but that looseness is part of the appeal. The hosts never turn it into a lecture; they talk about the game like something that was smarter than it first seemed. By the end, the episode has turned a retro title into a broader conversation about memory, repetition, old school educational design, and why it still works as a weirdly clean idea. The closing stretch returns to the show’s usual rhythm of listener plugs and credits. They mention Discord, Patreon, and their social channels, shout out the people who help with artwork and editing, and point to The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind as next week’s game. It ends with the same easygoing confidence it started with: a group of friends talking through a childhood artifact and moving on to the next one.

As heard by us

A loose retro-gaming discussion that makes a convincing case for the game's educational appeal.

The episode treats the game as edutainment, spending most of its time on how learning is folded into play. It points to the repetition, the quick visual cues, and the way questions about flags, currency, and place give the game its teaching edge.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Play this if you want retro-game banter, geography-flavored edutainment talk, and a silly title-editing question.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on