The Seven Criteria of Cancel Culture

·18 min·1 clip

James Lindsay reveals seven criteria to identify when you're watching an online cancellation attempt or struggle session.

The episode opens with James Lindsay introducing the topic as a 'New Discourses Bullets' segment, focusing on a concise breakdown of cancel culture. He mentions borrowing six criteria from a Twitter user with the handle Sarodinian1 and adding a seventh of his own. Lindsay first establishes that cancel culture and online struggle sessions are mass-scale phenomena, often described as pile-ons or Twitter storms. He then systematically walks through each criterion. The first is punitive versus corrective intent, where cancellation aims to punish rather than educate. The second is apparent organization, suggesting coordination among attackers through group chats or influencers. The third involves attempts to de-platform, such as dragging employers into the controversy. The fourth is secondary boycott threats, pressuring associates to disavow the target. The fifth is moral grandstanding, where attackers position themselves as morally superior. The sixth is disregard for factual accuracy, with attacks often misrepresenting the target's statements. The seventh, added by Lindsay, is victim-blaming, where the target is accused of bringing the cancellation on themselves. Throughout, Lindsay emphasizes that these criteria help identify inorganic, coordinated attacks rather than organic outrage. He advises listeners to recognize these patterns, refrain from participating, and rally to defend targets even if they disagree with them, arguing that cancellation is fundamentally wrong. The episode maintains an educational tone, with Lindsay speaking solo and referencing general examples without naming specific incidents.

As heard by us

A forceful framework for spotting how online punishment campaigns pressure others to disassociate from a target.

The episode lays out a seven-part framework for identifying what James Lindsay describes as a cancellation attempt or online struggle session.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a sharper way to recognize when an online pile-on becomes a cancellation attempt built around punishment.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from New Discourses