New Books in Religion · New Books Network

Daniel Wyche, "The Care of the Self and the Care of the Other: From Spiritual Exercises to Political Transformation" (Columbia UP, 2025)

January 17, 2026·1 hr 17 min·5 clips
Wyche argues that personal ethics alone can't drive political change without systemic organization and material analysis.
The conversation starts with the book's core question. Weisch is asked where the project comes from and what problem it is trying to solve, and he answers by linking practices of the self to the possibility of political transformation. Foucault comes up early. He uses Foucault to distinguish an analytics of power from a total theory of power, which keeps the discussion focused on how power is lived and interpreted rather than reduced to a slogan. The self is not treated as fixed. Instead, he argues that who and what we are is formed inside relations of power, many of them outside our control at first, so changes in the self inevitably touch the social world around it. That claim keeps widening. If the self is formed through those relations, then transforming the self can have effects on the forces that helped produce it, even if the result is indirect and uneven. The hosts return to definition. Weisch resists giving a single normative account of the self, because the argument has to work across different conceptions without pretending that every tradition shares the same anthropology. That restraint matters. It keeps the book from turning into a neat doctrine and lets the conversation ask how practices can be judged by what they do rather than by a preapproved label. The telos of practice becomes the next issue. Weisch talks about practices with multiple ends and about the way they can be tied to ethical formation, political life, and personal discipline at once. Left politics enters the frame. He notes that left movements can be plagued by infighting over conceptual precision, even while different commitments may still be able to work together ethically and politically. Resistance stays in view. The discussion circles back to how claims become legitimate, how rhetoric can police other statements, and why that matters for anyone trying to make room for dissent. The pace stays measured. That gives the episode room to turn dense theory into a clear, cumulative argument about selfhood, power, and transformation.

As heard by us

A serious interview about self-transformation and political possibility.

Daniel Weisch's interview asks what it means to treat care of the self as political practice. It moves patiently through Foucault and the idea that self-transformation can reach into the social forces and relations of power that shape people.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a careful New Books Network interview on how self-transformation can ripple into politics.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on