New Books in Indian Religions · Marshall Poe

Russell T. McCutcheon, "Our Primary Expertise: A Future for the Study of Religion" (Rutgers UP, 2025)

·53 min·4 clips
Russell McCutcheon was hired to revive a department on the brink of being cut, with only four and a half faculty and no tenure.
The interview centers on McCutcheon’s book. He treats the study of religion as a field that has to answer not only to scholarship, but also to the institutional conditions that decide what gets published, taught, and valued. That concern stays close to the surface. The host asks how the book came together, what problem it is meant to address, and why the present moment feels less like a routine disciplinary debate than a narrowing window for action. McCutcheon does not soften the stakes. He argues that many scholars, especially senior ones, have known for years that the field was moving into rough terrain, even if the hardest pressures have only become fully visible recently. The conversation gets candid. He expresses sympathy for younger colleagues facing a harsher job market and less stable prospects, but he also voices frustration that earlier generations did not confront the problem sooner. That frustration is not treated as resignation. Instead, it becomes part of a larger argument about criticism, optimism, and the need to keep asking how departments should be organized and who should shape their future. The interview keeps coming back to practical questions. McCutcheon and the host discuss whether too much of that work is left to senior scholars, and why more people in their early thirties should be writing and speaking up about where the discipline ought to go. The pace stays measured. Rather than chasing a single hot take, the discussion lets McCutcheon build a wider historical and institutional frame for his claims. That gives the episode its force. Listeners hear a scholar trying to connect his book to the realities of department life, publishing, and the long delay between having an idea and getting it into print. The language stays accessible without flattening the specialist terms. The closing note looks forward. The episode ends by pushing for more people to take a stab at the future of the study of religion rather than waiting for someone else to sort it out.

As heard by us

A serious conversation about the future of religious studies and who shapes it.

Russell T. McCutcheon turns to the future of religious studies, with attention to the strain on departments, senior scholars, and younger academics.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a sober conversation about where the study of religion is headed.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on