New Books in Indian Religions · Marshall Poe

Kathryn Hurlock, "Holy Places: How Pilgrimage Changed the World" (Profile, 2025)

·55 min·5 clips
Pilgrimage shapes everything from geopolitics to souvenir production, far beyond individual spiritual journeys.
The interview opens with Hurlock’s larger argument: pilgrimage has changed the world, not just one narrow corner of religious life. That idea stays at the center of the conversation. She and the host move through the medieval world, where pilgrimage studies are already well developed, and then widen the frame to ask what the modern period has missed. The gap matters. Hurlock says she expected to find far more scholarship on nineteenth- and twentieth-century pilgrimage in Europe and was surprised by how little there was. That surprise shapes the book’s direction. The conversation also returns to the categories pilgrimage studies often rely on, including miracles, cults, and saints, and keeps those terms intact rather than flattening them into vague spirituality. Eva Peron becomes the clearest test case. Hurlock uses her to show how devotional language can move into politics and public memory, since supporters treated her body in state, former offices, and the shrine that was planned for her as places of pilgrimage. The imagery is hard to miss. Even without formal canonization, the language around Evita, the descriptions of her as a Marian figure, and the effort to sanctify her memory all show how saint-like forms can survive outside official church structures. The interview lets that example breathe. It shows how a figure born into poverty, made famous through radio, and elevated into the first lady’s role could become the center of a devotional politics that still lingers. Hurlock’s scholarly interest stays broad. She traces the topic back to her training as a medievalist, then looks ahead to more work on modern pilgrimage and the archival and historical material that still has room to reshape the field. The book’s reach is wide. It asks how pilgrimage moves across centuries, how it attaches itself to new bodies and institutions, and why people keep returning to sacred or quasi-sacred places to make claims about memory and belonging. The tone stays measured. For listeners who like academic interviews that build an argument through examples, the episode gives a clear introduction to a book that treats pilgrimage as a changing social form with political, religious, and historical depth.

As heard by us

Pilgrimage is treated as more than church history, with Eva Peron used to widen the frame.

The book takes pilgrimage as a broad subject, moving from medieval pilgrimage, saints, and miracles into a modern example through Eva Peron. That wider reach is where the discussion starts to feel most alive, because it treats pilgrimage as political devotion as well as church…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

A patient look at how pilgrimage keeps changing across medieval and modern contexts.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on